On 17 September 2015 at 17:33, Mike Innes <mike.j.in...@gmail.com> wrote:

>
> Quick meta-note about this thread: I think it's important to emphasise
> that the julia-users list isn't designed to handle this kind of open-ended
> discussion. It's not that discussion is bad per se, but this list has a lot
> of subscribers who are mostly interested in sharply-focused technical
> issues – usually announcements or giving and receiving help. Topics that
> involve, say, debating the merits of various technologies are better suited
> to platforms such as reddit with features like comment threads for
> tangents, more focused notifications for other users, etc.
>

I don't agree. A Google group is well designed for open-ended discussion. I
receive a daily digest, where I can scan topics and subscribe only to the
ones that I find interesting. Also, the Julia community page does not
recommend any other forum for general discussion besides the users group.
Nor have am I aware of any official policy that when threads reach some
number of posts the participants are expected to relocate to Reddit. When
the time comes, and a new group is made for open-ended discussion about
Julia, I will be happy to subscribe to that group.

Just my two cents.

Cheers,
Daniel.

Reply via email to