Hi, while evaluating the interface of Kallithea, a user mentioned that there was no way for him to see which commits he already reviewed as a user. This got me thinking and reminded me on how this was done in Gerrit, based on that, I would like to do a RFC on this subject:
This is how it could work: * Once somebody opens a commit for review (in Kallithea it could be any commit), a 'flag' or 'mark' is set on that commit, that is has been viewed by you as user. * The user has the possibility to remove that flag (checkbox? floating checkbox in a corner?) before navigating to another page/commit/... * The user also has the possibility to disable this auto-flag behavior. * In case of (semi-)manual flagging, there are several options: - a user could choose to auto-set the flag once he makes his first comment - a user could choose to auto-set the flag once he approved/rejected a commit - a user could set the flag manually * In the changelog overview, besides the fact that a commit is approved/rejected, a flag could indicate that you as user have seen this commit (of approved/rejected it), this could be e.g. indicated by a red/green/grey border around the already present red/green/grey dot that indicates that the commit is in a review/pull request. please comment, Jan _______________________________________________ kallithea-general mailing list [email protected] http://lists.sfconservancy.org/mailman/listinfo/kallithea-general
