On Wed, Oct 1, 2008 at 10:09 AM, Darren New <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Bob La Quey wrote:
>>
>> Correct the WWW is loosely coupled, because HTTP is stateless. Again
>> see also Roy Fielding's thesis, which comment has been completely
>> ignored:
>
> Didn't really ignore it as such. It's just a relatively small bit of the
> protocols that go on.

The domain is much larger than most people realize. I am sure that you
know that ;-)

A good example of a RESTish approach is NetKernel. See http://1060.org/

> There are a number of ways to make things loosely coupled. REST is one, that
> only works well if your problem fits into that sort of domain. Almost none
> of the systems I've seen actually implement REST properly.

I would like to see some other good examples. Can you kindly provide
some links?

> For example, any web site with a custom login page isn't REST. Amazon's
>  cloud stuff isn't REST. They're all RESTish, but fail in the details that
> give you the benefits of REST.

I understand the login point as follows: sessions break REST. Is that
your point?

BobLQ

-- 
KPLUG-LPSG@kernel-panic.org
http://www.kernel-panic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/kplug-lpsg

Reply via email to