On Sunday 02 July 2006 14:36, Matthew Garrett wrote:
> On Sun, Jul 02, 2006 at 01:18:57PM +0200, Stephan Hermann wrote:
> > Well, there is a difference, because some keys are already handled
> > differently in KDE actually. But you are right, that if one Fn button is
> > working on KDE Desktop in Ubuntu everything else should work. Then we
> > need to test things like SD card support etc.
>
> If they're handled differently in KDE, then they shouldn't be. Hotkeys
> are exposed via the kernel input layer and also via dbus messages from
> HAL. That's entirely independent of whether the system is running
> Kubuntu or Ubuntu.

Well, KDE has kmilo, which had some special keys supported for IBM laptops, so 
there is a difference in the implementation.

Actually, in KDE there is no support for this HAL stuff, which will be changed 
for edgy (I hope).


> SD card support is, again, entirely independent of the desktop
> environment used. I have a mild preference to things being tested under
> Ubuntu because that's what I use (and I don't have the hard drive space
> to have kubuntu-desktop installed as well), but it really doesn't matter
> which one it's tested under.

Well, yes, the underlaying technology is the same, but the implementation is 
different. And this has to be tested, if or if not the underlaying technology 
is working on all different desktop flavours, not just one.

I think this has to be handled by the quality assurance crew, who should focus 
on those "little" things.

Regards,

\sh
-- 
SysAdmin and Linux Specialist
Freelancer, http://linux.blogweb.de/pages/cv.html
JID: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Attachment: pgp3KFNkANyuL.pgp
Description: PGP signature

-- 
laptop-testing-team mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/laptop-testing-team

Reply via email to