I just went through this exercise myself recently of figuring out how to 
account for loans. I wanted to record the expense over time instead of all 
up front. I don't have a loan out at the moment but I "refactored" my 
previous two loans, using a system like this:

2013/08/17 car dealer
    a: car: model 13                        $20,000
    l: loan: car: model 13                  $-20,000

2013/10/01 car dealer
    e: car: loan interest                   $25
    e: car: payment                         $300
    a: car: model 13                        $-300  ; depreciation
    l: loan: car: model 13                  $300
    a: checking: some bank                  $-325

I don't count my cars as assets, but using the asset account this way helps 
make it all work. I just depreciate it at exactly the same rate that I pay 
for it, so that when it's paid off it's worth nothing. :-)

On Tuesday, July 3, 2018 at 11:46:03 AM UTC-5, Shane wrote:
>
> I just bought a new vehicle and I'm not quite sure how I should go about 
> structuring accounts and transactions to give me the most accurate 
> reporting.
>
>    1. Should the car's value be an asset? How would I handle depreciation?
>    2. If the car is an asset, should I convert it to a commodity to track 
>    depreciation?
>    3. Should my down payment pay off the new liability account I created?
>    4. What account should interest be credited/debited to?
>
> Here is what I was thinking:
>
> // should the new car be an asset? would it be better to convert it to a 
> commodity?
> 2018-07-02=2018-07-02 * dealer
>     ; note: new car
>     ass:car                                 20,000.00 USD
>     lia:debt:car                           -20,000.00 USD
>
> // is it correct that my down payment should pay off the liability?
> 2018-07-02=2018-07-02 * dealer
>     ; note: down payment
>     lia:debt:car                            4,000.00 USD
>     ass:checking
>
> // where should interest go?
> 2018-08-01=2018-08-01 * bank
>     ; note: car payment
>     lia:debt:car                            1,000.00 USD
>     exp:interest:car?                       150.00 USD
>     ass:checking
>
> I would greatly appreciate some examples of how you tracked your new 
> vehicle.
>

-- 

--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Ledger" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to