Both Vint Cerf & Dave Young messages originally shared on Dave Farber's IP List at [email protected].
From: "Young, David E" <[email protected]> This reminds me of good old Congressman Schnell ( http://www.snopes.com/business/taxes/bill602p.asp) who was about to pass a law that would impose a surcharge on emails unless people immediately wrote to their members of Congress to voice their opposition. Of course, there was no such bill, nor even a Congressman Schnell. Yet that did not stop thousands of people from being tricked into sending letters to address a non-existent problem. Unfortunately, the same thing seems to be going on here. ** As someone who has been involved with the FCC’s Measuring Broadband America project from the beginning, let me provide a different perspective on this. First, the reason that the FCC’s broadband measurement program is open and that the data is freely available for academic use is because, to its credit, the FCC LEADERSHIP CHOSE TO RUN THE PROJECT THIS WAY. So, when the FCC and SamKnows chose to use M-Lab servers, the M-Lab’s disclosure requirements were consistent with what they had already planned to do. That said, had they not used M-Lab’s servers the FCC would still have released the data for study. Vint breathlessly suggests that the FCC is now backing away from this openness “at the bidding of the telcos” and claims the program is proposing to replace the M-Lab platform with only ISP-managed servers. THIS IS FALSE. ISPs have made no such request of the FCC nor has the FCC proposed to eliminate use of M-Lab’s servers. What has been proposed is that, in addition to continuing to use the data collected via the M-Lab servers, the FCC and SamKnows may also rely on the ISP provided servers that have been in use since the beginning of the project. These ISP-provided servers meet the specifications required by SamKnows as do the M-Labs servers. In fact, it was only because of the presence of these non-M-Lab, ISP-donated servers, that SamKnows was able to identify problems with an M-Lab server that was affecting the results of the tests being conducted. M-Labs did not identify this server problem on their own. It was only fixed when SamKnows brought the issue to their attention. By the way, this problem forced the FCC to abandon a month’s worth of test data, extend the formal test period and delay production of their report. Later, another M-Lab server location had transit problems that again affected results. This was the second M-Labs-related server problem in two months and once again, it was SamKnows, using the ISP-provided servers as a reference who identified the problem and brought it to M-Labs attention. The bottom line is that the ISP-provided servers, which meet the specs required by the FCC and SamKnows, have been part of the process from the inception of the Measuring Broadband America project and have repeatedly proven their value. The M-Lab servers will almost certainly continue to be used for this project, however the ISP-provided servers have proven that they can provide another source of data for use by the FCC in the event that M-Lab servers experience further problems. And, regardless, the FCC will continue its open data policy, whether the data is collected on M-Labs servers or not. I wish Vint and Google would save their prestige and influence to address the very real problems facing the global, open Internet and not waste your readers’ time with a “Congressman Schnell” exercise. -David *David E Young* VP Federal Regulatory Affairs**** Verizon**** 1300 I St NW, Suite 400W**** Washington, DC 20005**** ** ** +1-202-515-2517 (Office)**** +1-202-365-4755 (Cell)**** [email protected]
_______________________________________________ liberationtech mailing list [email protected] Should you need to change your subscription options, please go to: https://mailman.stanford.edu/mailman/listinfo/liberationtech If you would like to receive a daily digest, click "yes" (once you click above) next to "would you like to receive list mail batched in a daily digest?" You will need the user name and password you receive from the list moderator in monthly reminders. You may ask for a reminder here: https://mailman.stanford.edu/mailman/listinfo/liberationtech Should you need immediate assistance, please contact the list moderator. Please don't forget to follow us on http://twitter.com/#!/Liberationtech
