https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=153606
--- Comment #4 from alexandre burton <bur...@artificiel.org> --- hello! in the issue trackers i'm familiar with, if the issue is marked "resolved" it means it's closed -- in the sense that it's not open to discussion anymore. perhaps here it works differently. i'm not an apple guideline inspector, i'm reacting to my own experience, which is this: https://pasteboard.co/9PKU7UdN81ze.jpg and LO is diminutive and off-weight. as far as my take goes, the main reason i see is the duplication of "backgrounds" (esp white) and "outlines". the dark gray border should be the "squircle" BG, and the iconic white LO doc be within (like the mail enveloppe for example). and cutting the top-right corner of the squircle to have a pointed triangle float "out" of the squircle zone would be great (perhaps even with an alpha gap), support the consistency of the OS, and reaffirm the LO branding. very tight shadowing will bring sharpness in line with most other icons (even the non-squircles ones have tight shadows). the end game is to fit in the dock and task bar as it's where the icon is seen 99% of the time. but maybe my approach is distorted (when i mentioned the "LO community" it's because i assumed there was a collective process behind this (perhaps iterating), but as i understand it's more of an individual-based effort, which is fine). -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
