Comment #30 on issue 3026 by [email protected]: staff-padding should
measure to the alignment-points
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=3026
The property 'staff-padding' was in disagreement with its documentation in
version 2.16, possibly since it was first implemented. (See commennts 0,
16, 17)
The description of 'staff-padding' was and remains "Maintain this much
space between reference points and the staff."
Some values for 'staff-padding' were chosen based on the documentation,
such as the defaults for TrillSpanner that request one full staff-space
between the staff and the centerline of the spanner. Other values were
adjusted based on behavior of the program. Thus the single NOT_SMART rule
to mention the one change in behavior between 2.0-ish and 2.18.
The only temporary situation is Trevor's independent fix to the 2.17.x
documentation for aligning text on a baseline (which never really worked
before). This uses a clever trick with Y-extents, but that trick doesn't
work well in 2.16 because the Y-extent clears protruding notes, not just
the staff, in that version. Less confusing to fix the intended behavior.
Attachments:
old.png 5.9 KB
--
You received this message because this project is configured to send all
issue notifications to this address.
You may adjust your notification preferences at:
https://code.google.com/hosting/settings
