Hey all,
this is a feature request. I'm sorry, if this is already being discussed or
if a solution is coming behind the scenes. I couldn't find any message
other than a mention to
https://code.google.com/archive/p/lilypond/issues/3176. I find the lack of
a proper text spanner syntax uncomfortable. Using overrides is in my
opinion very inefficient (and most importantly, not very musical nor
readable). Since we already have some spanners with a more musical syntax
(\startTrillSpan, for example), I think something like this should be
common practice for text spanners as well.
I propose to use a syntax that contains the text and the style of the line
in the function, while allowing for custom text formatting. It would be a
type of \markup called \markupSpan. For example
\markupSpan { "sul pont." \arrow "sul tasto" }
c1\startMarkupSpan
c1\stopMarkupSpan
The new \startMarkupSpan would replace \startTextSpan. This \markupSpan
should combine ordinary markup text styles with line styles as in:
\markupSpan { \italic "vib." \dashed-line }
c1\startMarkupSpan
c1\stopMarkupSpan.
This would logically require renaming in general TextSpanner to
MarkupSpanner, but would tremendously improve usability and readability, in
my opinion. A tempo spanner would still be required if a markup spanner is
to be used simultaneously (so that the spanner that goes with the tempo
aligns with the next tempo automatically).
That being said, even more complex markup spanners would be possible using
\column:
\markupSpan {
\column {
\line { "sul pont." \arrow "sul tasto" }
\line {"vib." \dashed-line }
}}
c1\startMarkupSpan
c1\stopMarkupSpan
If all this could be combined with a \tempoSpan, it would be awesome!
Regards,
Martín.
--
www.martinrinconbotero.com
