Valentin Petzel <[email protected]> writes: >> Am Sonntag, 12. März 2023, 13:24:01 CET schrieb: >>> Valentin Petzel <[email protected]> writes: >>> > Regarding midi support: Personally I’d do this externally. Create an >>> > external program that records midi, either quantised real time or >>> > stepwise, and returns the output as Lilypond code. This then has the >>> > advantage that it is easier to maintain and can easily be used by >>> > whatever editor you want to use (as long as the editor in question >>> > allows you to call an external program and insert the output). >>> >>> An advantage of doing this in-editor is that you can reincorporate >>> manual duration corrections and bar checks into the quantisation. That >>> might significantly speed up the process of getting a good quantisation. >>> >>> Of course, Frescobaldi does not use timing at all yet, so that is a moot >>> point for now. > > > Yes, but an external program could do that too, without being tied to a > single > specific editor.
How do you propose an external program to incorporate edits without being an editor? -- David Kastrup
