Fellows,

  My Heartbeat set up is almost good to get into production. We just
need to decide and implement a better solution for the STONITH
procedure. We've been using the "dummy" solution so far.

  I have a somewhat unusual set up, with two clusters running MySQL
database servers: a "Replication Master Cluster" and a "Replication
Slave Cluster", both consisting of two identical hosts.

  I call my solution unusual because every node in both clusters is
located in a different data centre (I can not afford to stop my service
because I lost of connectivity with a single data centre).

  That means that there's little or no possibility of getting serial
access to the power console that controls the peer of a given host as
it's physically impossible to pull the necessary cables (for several
reasons).

  At this moment, I am working with mainly two alternatives: meatware or
a custom driver for STONITH, that will make a single SSH call with a
specially crafted key to trigger some action from the remote power console.

  As a solution, meatware is a proven, well-tested solution that is
distributed as part of the heartbeat standard software. It also doesn't
relies on the network, which is a good thing. On the down side, it
requires a human operator, causing long delays for the service take
over. It also will require more training for the operators, which is not
desirable (they have a lot in their plate, already).

  On the other hand, the promise of fast and automatic service recovery
without the intervention of a human operator, the lack of need for
operator specific training and know-how may compensate for the fact that
the solution depends on the Network and a custom driver, and it's not
largely tested (as all good home-grown solutions).

  Given that, I would like to have your technical advice. What solution
would you recommend me, given the aforementioned restrictions?

  Thanks a lot in advance.
  Regards.
-- 
Luis Motta Campos is a software engineer,
Perl Programmer, foodie and photographer.
_______________________________________________
Linux-HA mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.linux-ha.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-ha
See also: http://linux-ha.org/ReportingProblems

Reply via email to