Hi Krzysztof,
On 21 February 2016 at 07:07, Krzysztof Kozlowski
<k.kozlow...@samsung.com> wrote:
> 2016-02-20 4:30 GMT+09:00 Peter Hurley <pe...@hurleysoftware.com>:
>> [ +cc Krzysztof Kozlowski ]
>>
>> On 02/18/2016 09:15 PM, Anand Moon wrote:
>>> From: Anand Moon <linux.am...@gmail.com>
>>>
>>> drop the spin_unlock/lock around uart_write_wakeup to protect
>>> write wakeup for uart port.
>>
>> What Krzysztof was saying wrt v1 of this patch is that the
>> changelog should provide as much information as possible to
>> the maintainer(s) and driver author(s), and that you should
>> test that outcome.
>>
>> Here's what I would have written for a commit message:
>>
>>
>> Remove deadlock workaround for line disciplines that invoke
>> the tty driver's write() method directly from their write_wakeup()
>> method. As documented for the write_wakeup() line discipline method
>> in tty_ldisc.h, line disciplines must not attempt i/o directly
>> from write_wakeup() as this will deadlock. Reviews of in-tree line
>> disciplines confirm all defer i/o.
>>
>> NB: This workaround was added in commit c15c3747ee32
>> ("serial: samsung: fix potential soft lockup during uart write")
>> which notes both slip and bluetooth hci attempt i/o directly from
>> write_wakeup(). These issues were fixed in commits 661f7fda21b1
>> ("slip: Fix deadlock in write_wakeup") and da64c27d3c93
>> ("bluetooth: hci_ldisc: fix deadlock condition"), respectively.
>
> Thanks Peter for thorough analysis. It shouldn't be done by you but by
> the patch submitter... and I have big worries that Anand did not
> perform that analysis.
>
> Anand, could you at least test that this lockup does not happen
> anymore? You will need board with Bluetooth for that (and not USB
> Bluetooth...). If you cannot test it, maybe guys from Polish R&D could
> help you (Cc-ed), because they were working on DMA for serial used in
> Bluetooth.
>
> Best regards,
> Krzysztof
I have looked into the history of the changes,
commit c15c3747ee32 (serial: samsung: fix potential soft lockup during
uart write)
was added long time ago, that's why have missed this.
I don't have on-board Bluetooth enable boards with me,
so if their is potential lockup you people observer
do not consider this patch.
My change's were on the perception of the locking/unlocking.
Thanks for your inputs.
Best regards,
-Anand Moon
