Hi Ganesh, On Tue, Apr 10, 2018 at 04:52:58PM +0800, Ganesh Mahendran wrote:
< snip > > >> base patch_v1 patch_v5 > >> ----------------------------------------------------------- > >> 91223.4 90560.2 89644.5 > >> 90520.3 89583.1 89048.2 > >> 89833.2 90247.6 90091.3 > >> 90740.2 90276.7 90994.2 > >> 89703.5 90112.4 89994.6 > >> 89945.1 89122.8 88937.7 > >> 89872.8 90357.3 89307.4 > >> 89913.2 90355.4 89563.8 > >> 88979 90393.4 90182.8 > >> 89577.3 90946.8 90441.4 > >> AVG 90030.8 90195.57 89820.59 > > > > Yes, no regression. > > > >> > >> Before the test, I stop the android framework by: > >> adb shell stop > >> > >> > > >> > Please tell me more detail. What apps are slower compared to old? > >> > Every apps are slowed with avg 15%? Then, what's the stddev? > >> > >> Not all of the apps slowed 15%, The app *avg* launch time slowed 15%. > >> And We will re-launch the test tomorrow: base, v1,v5. We will get the > >> test result in two days later. Then I will post all the app launch time > >> details. > > > > I'm also trying to make stable result in my side but it's really hard to > > get. Please post stddev of each app as well as avg when you finished > > testing. > > I really appreicate you. > > What do you mean by stddev? Standard deviation. > > We test 80 loops and launch ~40 apps in each loop. > Below is the app launch time result: > > app base v1 diff percent v5 diff percent > ---- > com.tencent.mobileqq 829 834 5 1% 879 50 6% > com.tencent.qqmusic 799 790 -9 -1% 764 -35 -4% > com.tencent.mtt 659 655 -4 -1% 979 320 49% > com.UCMobile 1149 1144 -5 0% 927 -222 -19% > com.qiyi.video 1557 1579 22 1% 1497 -60 -4% > com.baidu.BaiduMap 1137 1136 -1 0% 1096 -41 -4% > tv.danmaku.bili 3642 3655 13 0% 3538 -104 -3% > com.sdu.didi.psnger 4334 4352 18 0% 4224 -110 -3% > com.ss.android.ugc.aweme 1958 1970 12 1% 1884 -74 -4% > air.tv.douyu.android 3333 3371 38 1% 3251 -82 -2% > me.ele 3183 3182 -1 0% 3178 -5 0% > com.autonavi.minimap 1920 1922 2 0% 1868 -52 -3% > com.duowan.kiwi 1452 1457 5 0% 1349 -103 -7% > com.v.study 3549 3558 9 0% 3519 -30 -1% > com.qqgame.hlddz 4074 4060 -14 0% 4443 369 9% > com.ss.android.article.news 1631 1680 49 3% 1649 18 1% > com.jingdong.app.mall 1448 1443 -5 0% 1323 -125 -9% > com.tencent.tmgp.pubgmhd 1703 1706 3 0% 1601 -102 -6% > com.kugou.android 854 862 8 1% 791 -63 -7% > com.kuaikan.comic 1341 1374 33 2% 2118 777 58% > com.smile.gifmaker 798 686 -112 -14% 642 -156 -20% > com.hunantv.imgo.activity 1560 1616 56 4% 1569 9 1% > com.mt.mtxx.mtxx 1746 1838 92 5% 1773 27 2% > com.sankuai.meituan 3610 3697 87 2% 3551 -59 -2% > com.sankuai.meituan.takeoutnew 3376 3387 11 0% 3325 -51 -2% > com.meitu.meiyancamera 1905 2010 105 6% 1870 -35 -2% > com.tencent.karaoke 888 906 18 2% 896 8 1% > com.taobao.taobao 3344 3406 62 2% 3368 24 1% > com.tencent.qqlive 1314 1345 31 2% 1499 185 14% > com.tmall.wireless 3746 3735 -11 0% 3699 -47 -1% > com.tencent.tmgp.sgame 3250 3513 263 8% 3707 457 14% > com.netease.cloudmusic 2550 2570 20 1% 2546 -4 0% > com.sina.weibo 2201 2240 39 2% 2191 -10 0% > com.tencent.mm 638 645 7 1% 690 52 8% > com.immomo.momo 1536 1554 18 1% 1563 27 2% > com.xiaomi.hm.health 915 926 11 1% 888 -27 -3% > com.youku.phone 1881 1820 -61 -3% 1880 -1 0% > com.eg.android.AlipayGphone 1536 1557 21 1% 1624 88 6% > com.meituan.qcs.c.android 3140 3533 393 13% 3171 31 1% > ----- > average 2064 2095 31 1.50% 2085 21 1% > > 1% is in the fluctuating range of our tool. > So no obvious regression found in app launch time. Thanks. Greg, Ganesh finally confirmed there is no regression. Could you pick up the patch?