Hello Andry, Tuesday, April 09, 2002, 6:20:11 PM, you wrote: AS> Saya ingin tanya: <cut> AS> 4.Apa aja sih keunggulan .NET dan kekurangannya? AS> 5.Apa pula kekurangan dan kelebihan J2EE? AS> 6.Selain java, bahasa pemograman apa yang jalan di AS> mesin-nya Sun? AS> Harap maklum dengan pertanyaan saya ini, karena saya AS> masih awam dengan Enterprise programming, apalagi AS> mesin Sun itu sendiri, yang katanya pakai procesor AS> Ultra SPARC III, dan sebentar lagi akan menggunakan AS> Ultra SPARC IV(menurut orang Sun)? AS> Thanks, AS> Andry.
dr orang awam juga ^^; kebetulan pernah dapetin perbandingan antara J2EE dan .Net..di java.sun.com kalo ngga salah (atau download aja di www.middleware-company.com, pdf, 1.62MB judulnya J2EE vs .NET)... isinya : (perbandingannya aja) copy&paste.... ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arguments supporting both platforms (J2EE & .NET) � Regardless of which platform you pick, new developers will need to be trained (Java training for J2EE, OO training for .NET) � You can build web services today using both platforms � Both platforms offer a low system cost, such as jBoss/Linux/Cobalt for J2EE, or Windows/Win32 hardware for .NET. � Both platforms offer a single-vendor solution. � The scalability of both solutions are theoretically unlimited. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Arguments for .NET and against J2EE � .NET has Microsoft's A-team marketing it � .NET released their web services story before J2EE did, and thus has some mind-share � .NET has a better story for shared context today than J2EE � .NET has an awesome tool story with Visual Studio.NET � .NET has a simpler programming model, enabling rank-and-file developers to be productive without shooting themselves in the foot � .NET gives you language neutrality when developing new eBusiness applications, whereas J2EE makes you treat other languages as separate applications � .NET benefits from being strongly interweaved with the underlying operating system ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Arguments for J2EE and against .NET � J2EE is being marketed by an entire industry � J2EE is a proven platform, with a few new web services APIs. .NET is a rewrite and introduces risk as with any first-generation technology � Only J2EE lets you deploy web services today � Existing J2EE code will translate into a J2EE web services system without major rewrites. Not true for Windows DNA code ported to .NET. � .NET web services are not interoperable with current industry standards. Their BizTalk framework has proprietary SOAP extensions and does not support ebXML. � J2EE is a more advanced programming model, appropriate for well-trained developers who want to build more advanced object models and take advantage of performance features � J2EE lets you take advantage of existing hardware you may have � J2EE gives you platform neutrality, including Windows. You also get good (but not free) portability. This isolates you from heterogeneous deployment environments. � J2EE has a better legacy integration story through the Java Connector Architecture (JCA) � J2EE lets you use any operating system you prefer, such as Windows, UNIX, or mainframe. Developers can use the environment they are most productive in. � J2EE lets you use Java, which is better than C# due to market-share and maturity. According to Gartner, there are 2.5 million Java developers. IDC predicts this will grow to 4 million by 2003. 78% universities teach Java, and 50% of universities require Java. � We would not want to use any language other than C# or Java for development of new missioncritical solutions, such as a hacked object-oriented version of C, VB, or COBOL. � We are finding most ISVs and consulting companies going with J2EE because they cannot control their customers' target platforms. We believe this application availability will result in J2EE beginning to dominate more and more as time goes on. ------------------------------------------------------------------------ CONCLUSION : In conclusion, while both platforms will have their own market-share, we feel most customers will reap greater wins with J2EE. We feel the advantages outweigh those offered by Microsoft.NET. That is our preferred architecture, and we stand behind it. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- denger2x kalao J2EE di windows jalanya lambat yah...trus MS kan juga berusaha menjegal J2EE ya itu dengan cara tidak support javaVM lagi pada IE 6.0nya... .Net source codenya juga direlease (cari di msdn.com) dengan lisensi shared source (sejenis open source tapi tidak sebebas open source). Dr apa yg aku pernah baca .NET rasanya ditolak oleh beberapa universitas dan mereka lebih menyukai menggunakan Java...artikelnya ada kok di slashdot.org beberapa hari yg lalu. Nah gimana dengan dotGNU ????? kok ngga dibicarain sih ? harusnya J2EE vs .Net vs dotGNU donk...biar rame hehehe... (yg .GNU kok jarang denger yah...ini proyek serius apa ngga sih ?) -- Best regards, adwin -- Utk berhenti langganan, kirim email ke [EMAIL PROTECTED] Informasi arsip di http://www.linux.or.id/milis.php3
