> Now that makes perfect sense. Suetin must have rejected these pieces > as just so much garbage, enough to cause Koshkin to spread rumors > about him and his father which would make your scurrilous writings > like a pleasant walk in the park. Perhaps I should ask Nikita for > permission to publish his e-mail message to me Dated Thu, 11 Jan 2001 > 18:32:29 +0300, detailing his opinions of Suetin. I have a good > occasion to pose him this question. I am planning to post on blog > later today a part of your message regarding my editions as > maculatura, and ask both Koshkin and Gilardino, composers I have > published and whose music is included in my free bonus program, if > the would agree that your characterization of their music as > maculatura is acceptable to them. Considering the whopping dozen people that read your blog: post your rotten heart's content. Make our day.
> > > > > Also, your newly found love affair with Koshkin, so soon after you > > > denounced me for publishing the music of Koshkin/Myshkin, right here > > > in this forum, is almost a year old by now. How come it had taken him > > > all that time to tell you about his lute compositions? > > > Anyway, a side show of little interest. > >Not really. At least this is lutenistically relevant, > > As relevant as all the other hearsay rumors we have been reading > recently in this forum. It will become relevant when, and if, it is > ever published, and if in fact it was ever composed, which I doubt > very much. As one composer who has been distributing copies of his > manuscripts years before they were submitted for publication, Koshkin > would have surely sent you copies of his lute music as soon as you > became his LJ friend. The fact that he did not even tell you about it > until now, only means that it does not exist, and therefore, not > lutenistically relevant. Would yoy mind making a decision whether to allege EITHER non-existence OR substandard quality. You cannot claim both at the same time. RT To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
