Yes - I understood this. My note was simply in response to GC's comment that high photo costs were a major obstacle - and I pointed out that this was really only the case if one required a very high quality facsimile and that most players are perfectly satisfied with something they can play from (eg the SPES 'facsimiles'). Agree that the collections need to be encouraged to produce low cost copies - I'm afraid some of the British institutions are amongsat the worst offenders................. The digitalization of the Boije collection (available free!) shows what can be done with the will. MH
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: --- Martyn Hodgson wrote: > > In practice I find that the vast majority of > players are very happy with a plain black and white > print produced by less high quality reproduction > techniques such as those available from SPES (at a > fraction of BP prices). > It seems there has been some mis-communication about this thread based on different assumptions. Steve and Gordon are assuming that we're talking about actual access to the original item itself which, as Gordon mentioned in another post, can in fact be absolutely needed. Certain types of scholarly projects of course need this kind of examination of unique attributes. Rather than these types of scholarship, the issue that I believe Alfonso intitially brought up was the in-accesability to just the _information_ contained in these sources. If I remember correctly, he complained about being charged a high price just for rental of a microfilm. He probably didn't care too much about fly-specks or watermarks; he just wanted to play the music. This hardly requires the high-quality/cost reproduction process that is used for more serious endeavours. This kind of policy effectively _does_ cut off your average Joe Blow amateur-, semi-serious-, or even serious-level performer from getting to the stuff. Would the library folks really rather have it that needless numbers folks physically travel to the building and get their grubby hands of the fragile original? It would seem that making low-quality reproductions would cut down on preservation and repair costs in the long run. Chris ____________________________________________________________________________________ Looking for earth-friendly autos? Browse Top Cars by "Green Rating" at Yahoo! Autos' Green Center. http://autos.yahoo.com/green_center/ --------------------------------- Yahoo! Answers - Got a question? Someone out there knows the answer. Tryit now. -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html
