Richard Heck wrote:

> On 04/22/2012 07:23 PM, Uwe Stöhr wrote:
>> The last days I had to write a report containing subscripts in almost
>> every paragraph and got annoyed that one cannot set some text as a
>> sub- or superscript via the text style dialog. I therefore propose to
>> enhance the text style dialog to a "position" field.

If you need a physical formatting tool that often it might be a hint that 
you either need semantic markup (e.g. a character style), or a macro. Can 
you give an example, or is the contents secret?

>> I mean we have in the text style dialog already the text size, color
>> and shape. So why not also the position? Having it there would also
>> ease up its usage as one then can highlight some text and press the
>> Apply Last toolbar button as for all other text features.
>>
> Why is it easier to do this than to highlight the text and hit
> "Insert>Formatting>Subscript", which is my case is just Alt-I, O, B?
> There's also a reason not to do it via the Text Style dialog: Everything
> else in that dialog is represented as a range, whereas scripts are
> insets. That will make using the dialog for this much more complicated
> than it might seem at first.

Indeed. IMO, if the scripts are handled by the dialog, they should be ranges 
as well. Otherwise you will get lots of surprises. Initially I thought of 
implementing them as ranges, but then I came to the conclusion that an inset 
is better, both from a users POV (when do you need to mix sub/superscripts 
with other formatting like language or italic?) and implementation wise.


Georg

Reply via email to