Dear Scot, dear Docutils developers,

On 2017-09-04, Scott Kostyshak wrote:


>> The problem is, however, that users upgrading from 2.2 have read the
>> 2.2.0 RELEASE NOTES already and won't see the need to re-read them,

> Agreed.

>> thus missing the information. Nevertheless, they are still affected by
>> the changes when opening pre-2.2 documents (and will forever, as we
>> voted not to revert the decision to merge literal and ligature dashes
>> in the LyX source). 

> You are thinking maybe of a user who created their document with 2.1.x,
> edited it briefly in 2.2.x but not enough to realize a change/problem,
> and now are upgrading to 2.3.0 and will be reading the release notes? 

I am looking for the right place of a warning to all users of LyX 2.2 and
newer, as they may see problems with dashes in documents created with
version up to 2.1.

> I think we can address it with e.g. a concise "if you created the first
> version of your document in LyX pre-2.2, your dashes may have been
> changed. For more information, please see..." I think that makes more
> sense that putting a lot of details about this issue in the 2.3.0
> release notes. I think that the important thing is to let the user know
> the conditions under which they might experience a caveat.

> I don't really have a strong opinion on this, but I think a concise
> description of the conditions for a caveat, combined with a reference
> for further information, could be a reasonable compromise.

Agreed. I will prepare a patch for review.

Günter

Reply via email to