This is mostly a recommendation for a small change to the User's
Guide. If the change has been made in LyX 1.6 (I'm still on LyX 1.5.7,
WinXP, examples in basic article class), or if I have otherwise
blundered in proffering advice (known to happen), I apologize. I've
been a LyX user for a long while now, but often discover simple things
I should already know.

I suggest that the description of how spacing is handled around floats
(figure floats in my case) can be improved slightly in the User's
Guide. In particular, I am referring to the advice in section 4.6,
which seems incomplete:

"It is recommended to insert floats as a separate paragraph to avoid
possible LaTeX-errors that can occur when the surrounding text is
specially formatted."

Without specific advice about how to center a floated figure in the
document, this advice leaves the user an unclear impression of how to
proceed. Intuitively (perhaps), one would change the paragraph
settings for the environment containing the widget, but that would not work well
and would leave a nasty space where
the float was inserted (not where it ends up). What the user probably
wants a figure float set in its own environment as recommended
above, but with the graphic in the float centered by changing the
paragraph settings for the graphic *within* the float. This leaves the
widget at left in the LyX view, which corresponds with the collapsed
floats in the User's Guide (a hint?). To me this behavior is not
intuitive and in fact may also be undesirable for editing purposes --
personally I'd prefer the widgets centered through, making them easy
to find like display equations. As far as I can tell, there is no way
to center those widgets in the display without causing a problem in
the output.

-- 
Dave Hewitt
Klamath Falls, Oregon

Reply via email to