You have to switch to day view to see a list.  Personally I think a list view 
should be added to the toolbar.

I wrote to Apple expressing my disappointment with Calendar and felt it should 
be more intuitive, be more iOS like and require less interacting.

This is my observation of the app as you explore, starting with the toolbar:

There is the toolbar which you can interact with. I think another view should 
be added to the calendar view switcher.  I think there should be a "List View". 
 This would make the calendar behave more like iOS.  I also think the Today 
button should be moved to the toolbar as well as a button for invitations and 
for adding a new calendar.

After you stop interacting with the toolbar, there is the vertical splitter  
(why do we need to care about this? I would rather not hear VO announce this.  
I can appreciate it is there for when you bring the list of calendar types into 
view.  Perhaps calendar view should actually be moved to the view menu at the 
top of the window.  There could be an entry called Calendars, with a sub menu 
which you can then place a tick against the calendar or calendars you which to 
be be visible such as all calendars, home, work, birthdays etc.
) After the vertical splitter, VO says "Friday, 10 August 2012, year, Calendar 
area" (this is the date of myself writing this message, and I had the year view 
selected) ). I think it would sound better if VO rad all this out as "Today is 
the 10th of August 2012, Year view is selected".

Next, as long as you do not interact with the calendar area,  there is a 
horizontal splitter, yet again, why does VO even need to know this?

I have my calendar currently set to year view, so let's interact with it and 
explore that.

The first item is the previous year button,  and the next item is the today 
button, should this not say what the current year is? for example 2012?  No 
matter which view I use, the today button is always read out which is not 
relevant when in month or year or week view, this should behave more like iOS.  
.  The next element is next year button.

Next is The 2012 (or whichever year you have selected).  VO tells you this is a 
grid and tells you how many rows and columns there are.  Is this relevant? and 
why do we even need to interact with this grid?  Should it not be visible by 
default?  This is one of my biggest complains about the calendar app, there are 
too many levels to interact with.  Can you imagine how popular google search 
would be if you had to follow 6 hyperlinks before you finally got to the search 
box?

After interacting, I am told by VO that I am on August, and that is the 8 of 12 
 and lists the number of columns and rows within that month.  Again, is this 
relevant? do we really need to know how many rows and columns can be found 
inside August? and do I need to be told it is month 8 of 12?

Next we have to interact with August to see each of the days.  Now this bit I 
think Apple got right, as you don't want to have to listen to every entry for 
every month, it is nice being able to skip over months and simply only 
interacting with the month you require.  

Ok, so I have now interacted with the month of August and I am still in year 
view. and I move to 14, and VO tells me this is a Tuesday (great as we never 
got this in the past) but it also tells me I am on 16 of 42.  Why is the 16 of 
42 relevant?  .  I have an event on the 14th August, but VO has not announced 
anything about this when I move my VO cursor over the 14th (I am using the VO 
keys plus arrows left and right to move the VO cursor).   I would like VO to 
say at least 1 event listed, press VO plus space to view the event.  When I do 
press VO + space (even though there was no hint to do so) I finally hear a pop 
up which displays my event, and then I hit escape to make it go away. There is 
no option within the pop up to then list the event in full or be able to edit 
the event, these options would be useful.

Ok that is the year view, let's look at month view.

the first element is previous month and the next month is today (which should 
say the current month, in my case is August), then we have the next month 
button.. Next follows "August 2012 grid, 5 rows 7 columns" again, why do I need 
to know the number of rows and columns? and why do I have to interact with the 
grid? it should be visible by default.  .  After interacting, I land on 30 July 
which is a Monday. and voiceover announces "1 event list", maybe it would be 
better if VO said "1 event" to be consistent with iOS.  This is good though, as 
in month view you are informed you have an event listed when you move the VO 
cursor over the day, as I mentioned earlier VO does not announce this when in 
Year view.  The next thing VO tells me after announcing the event, that I am on 
1 of 35.  Yet again, do I really need to know I am on 1 of 35?

I am now going to explore the week view.  As usual we have the previous button 
and in this case it is the previous week button.  There is then the today 
button, I would rather this was text that said the date of the week I am 
looking at and the week number in the year would b a nice touch too.  There is 
the next week button after that.  The next item confuses me some what, as it is 
called the dates group and when you interact with it you can do very little 
apart from hear day headers.  Seems absolutely useless, so I think VO should 
not even see this.  The next item is the week grid which you can interact with 
and see each of the days for that week.  You then have to interact yet again to 
see the contents of each of the days to establish if any of them are holding 
events.  Get rid of the dates group, and make it so the week grid is interacted 
with by default. and then when you interact with each of the days it will not 
seem so bad. We also yet again do not need to know about row and colin numbers 
etc.

Let's now look at day view. We have the usual previous day button, then the 
today button (should this not actually say what the actual day selected is? So 
in my case, it should say "30 July 2012".  Then we have the next day button.   
Next I then hear "all day events, empty scroll area", this is another thing I 
can interact with and then is the current day I have listed, this seems to be 
in the wrong place for me and should have been on the today button. Then you 
finally get to the list of  events.  Would it not be much simpler to have the 
list of events for that day only (including all day events)? When in an all day 
event mode, I would like to be able to move my cursor between the different 
hours of the day to see what is where and when, in the same way this can be 
achieved in iOS when looking at day view or using other calendar apps such as 
Outlook for example.

My final complaint is a bug I have found when creating a new event.  First of 
all when creating a new event, it seems like we are forced into creating a 
quick event, but what if you want to be more detailed? When you are finally 
able to interact with the inspector, I have noticed a focus issue bug when 
selecting the time of the reminder. If I change it from the default of 30 
minutes to something else, my VO cursor is thrown up to the location field.  I 
then have to work my way down again and then if I say select the type of alert 
I would like, either a message and or sound etc, I am then thrown back up to 
the location field, I then make my way back down to select the sound I would 
like to hear when I am notified of the reminder, after selecting I am thrown 
back up to the top.  This is an ongoing loop every time I try to change one of 
the settings within the inspector.

Chris 

On 14 Aug 2012, at 13:42, Steve Holmes <[email protected]> wrote:

> I have a question about the list of appointments possible in Calendar.  On 
> IOS devices, you can see a full list view of all appointments, past and 
> present in a single view.  I was thinking since Mountain Lion's approach in 
> many apps is more closely similar to their IOS counterparts,, that list could 
> be shown on the Mac as well.  Alas, I haven't been able to do that.  Is a 
> single list of all events even possible on the Mac? I can get a list within a 
> specific period of time like week or month view but I would like to see the 
> list like I can on my iPod.
> 
> Any ideas?
> 
> -- 
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
> "MacVisionaries" group.
> To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
> To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
> [email protected].
> For more options, visit this group at 
> http://groups.google.com/group/macvisionaries?hl=en.
> 

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"MacVisionaries" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/macvisionaries?hl=en.

Reply via email to