Thanks for all your valuable feedbacks. Regarding to security issues for alpha features: I completely agree with Larry: ideally, all alpha features should be disabled by default.
Steve/Arun/Haibo: could you please comment about feature's rough merge plan and status (like alpha/beta). I will wait several days to see if there are any other features wanted to be added to 3.1 before creating initial release scope/plan on confluent. Best, Wangda On Thu, Sep 7, 2017 at 12:14 PM, Haibo Chen <haiboc...@cloudera.com> wrote: > Thanks Wangda for initiating 3.1.0 release efforts. One YARN feature I'd > like to add to 3.1.0 is YARN Oversubscription (YARN-1011) > > Best, > Haibo > > On Wed, Sep 6, 2017 at 11:13 AM, Wangda Tan <wheele...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> Hi all, >> >> As we discussed on [1], there were proposals from Steve / Vinod etc to >> have >> a faster cadence of releases and to start thinking of a Hadoop 3.1 release >> earlier than March 2018 as is currently proposed. >> >> I think this is a good idea. I'd like to start the process sooner, and >> establish timeline etc so that we can be ready when 3.0.0 GA is out. With >> this we can also establish faster cadence for future Hadoop 3.x releases. >> >> To this end, I propose to target Hadoop 3.1.0 for a release by mid Jan >> 2018. (About 4.5 months from now and 2.5 months after 3.0-GA, instead of >> 6.5 months from now). >> >> I'd also want to take this opportunity to come up with a more elaborate >> release plan to avoid some of the confusion we had with 3.0 beta. General >> proposal for the timeline (per this other proposal [2]) >> - Feature freeze date - all features should be merged by Dec 15, 2017. >> - Code freeze date - blockers/critical only, no more improvements and non >> blocker/critical bug-fixes: Jan 1, 2018. >> - Release date: Jan 15, 2018 >> >> Following is a list of features on my radar which could be candidates for >> a >> 3.1 release: >> - YARN-5734, Dynamic scheduler queue configuration. (Owner: Jonathan Hung) >> - YARN-5881, Add absolute resource configuration to CapacityScheduler. >> (Owner: Sunil) >> - YARN-5673, Container-executor rewrite for better security, extensibility >> and portability. (Owner Varun Vasudev) >> - YARN-6223, GPU isolation. (Owner: Wangda) >> >> And from email [3] mentioned by Andrew, there’re several other HDFS >> features want to be released with 3.1 as well, assuming they fit the >> timelines: >> - Storage Policy Satisfier >> - HDFS tiered storage >> >> Please let me know if I missed any features targeted to 3.1 per this >> timeline. >> >> And I want to volunteer myself as release manager of 3.1.0 release. Please >> let me know if you have any suggestions/concerns. >> >> Thanks, >> Wangda Tan >> >> [1] http://markmail.org/message/hwar5f5ap654ck5o?q= >> Branch+merges+and+3%2E0%2E0-beta1+scope >> [2] http://markmail.org/message/hwar5f5ap654ck5o?q=Branch+ >> merges+and+3%2E0%2E0-beta1+scope#query:Branch%20merges% >> 20and%203.0.0-beta1%20scope+page:1+mid:2hqqkhl2dymcikf5+state:results >> [3] http://markmail.org/message/h35obzqrh3ag6dgn?q=Branch+merge >> s+and+3%2E0%2E0-beta1+scope >> > >
