On Tuesday, June 28, 2011 12:44:18 PM Alessandro Vesely wrote: > On 28/Jun/11 15:42, Scott Kitterman wrote: > > On Tuesday, June 28, 2011 09:35:07 AM [email protected] wrote: > > ... > > > >> Title : SPF Authentication Failure Reporting using the Abuse > >> > >> Report Format Author(s) : Scott Kitterman > > > > ... > > > > This is the first draft of the split out document. Please review and let > > me know how it can be improved. > > I have some comments on both I-Ds. Actually, there should be three > I-Ds, so my comments perhaps are about the missing one. One point is > the reference to [I-D.MARF-DKIM-REPORTING]. Shouldn't that refer to > the missing I-D, i.e. RFCxxxx "Abuse Report Format (ARF) Extensions > for Authentication Failure Reporting" instead?
Yes. It should. I'm hoping that one will be done soon (I'm not the one doing it). I also have a couple of downrefs to sort out. > I liked the idea of splitting the documents, but would now recommend > factoring some text where possible. > > A second point is the idea of a "conditional" report. That may mean, > e.g., only send me an SPF-failure report if you verified a DKIM > signature for the same domain name. By enabling reporting, one will > likely receive an inordinate amount of spam generated notifications: > it will be useful to check mail settings of a new domain, but will > turned off after a short time. Conditional reporting, instead, can be > kept permanently enabled. What do you think? I'm not sure how useful that would be since that would get you reports for any mail that was forwarded as well. I suspect the reverse, send a DKIM failure report if SPF passed for the same domain might be useful, but I suspect complex enough to take up as a separate topic. > Third point, an example of a complete report would be appreciated. I think that goes in the still missing Abuse Report Format (ARF) Extensions for Authentication Failure Reporting. Once I see what's covered in that draft, I may have additions for this one, we'll see. Scott K _______________________________________________ marf mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/marf
