You seem to be confusing two things.

>For /abuse/ reporting, however, the domain-part of the discovered
>address could make a difference when a feedback generator is about to
>choose among this and, say, abuse POCs found in whois databases.

Well, sure.  If you find an address you trust some other way, send
reports to it.


> Consider
>  _report.myunknowndomain.name. TXT "[email protected]"

Speaking both in general, and specifically as Mr. abuse.net, this is
precisely what I want to forbid.  I cannot tell you how many lazy or
incompetent ISPs have foisted off some problem by telling their users
to report it to abuse.net, which is of course completely useless and
a waste of both the user's time and mine.

I realize that we could invent some DNS thing with extra text records
that are supposed to cross reference in some way, but I see no reason
to invent yet more mechanism.  If you've outsourced your abuse
handling to someone else, we already know how to add a single line in
your mail config to forward your abuse address to them.  At last that
way when some bozo forwards his complaints to me without asking, I
only have one address to blacklist.

R's,
John
_______________________________________________
marf mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/marf

Reply via email to