Tom Knapp wrote:

TK) Interesting proposition. (TK

Not to Susan Hogarth.  She quickly replied "thanks but no thanks" and
censored the offer from reaching the LPradicals group.  This invites the
inference that she's afraid of people finding out the Radical Caucus is not
quite so radical.  Or maybe she's so radical that she won't take money for
the radical cause from a non-radical...

TK) Are you the author of this pledge, or is it a pre-existing document from
some other source? (TK

I wrote it myself yesterday, and (to quote George Costanza) it didn't even
take very long either.  One sentence is borrowed nearly whole from
Rothbard's 1978 LNC strategy resolution.

TK) If you need help correcting it (some of it does not, in fact, "follow
straightforwardly from," etc.), let me know, though. (TK

I would love help from radicals in figuring out what parts of the pledge do
not follow naturally from an absolute commitment to never endorse the
initiation of force through any law, regulation, or practice.  If nobody in
the Radical Caucus has got enough radical game to take the Pledge as is,
then we could treat it as The World's Radical-est LP Pledge Quiz and
separate the almost-radicals from the wannabes.  I score 0% (0/30).  How
about you?  (For scoring purposes, "this pledge" can be taken to mean just
the parts of the pledge that the pledger pledges, provided the pledger
pledges to at least one part that doesn't merely reference the pledge.)

TK) I AM interested in the disposition of the piece as intellectual
property. All rights reserved? (TK

Since Susan turned down the donated text, I'll henceforth include the
following with it: "This pledge was written by Brian Holtz, who in the
reproduction of expression opposes only fraud and so does not believe in
copyright.  If you do believe in copyright, then this text is protected
under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 license, and may be used in any way
provided the use cites Brian Holtz as the original author and
http://marketliberal.org/No1stForce.html as the latest version."

TK) I may be interested in distributing it as a pamphlet/brochure at the
national convention under auspices other than those of the Radical Caucus.
I'm thinking of titling it "HOLTZ SPEAKS OUT: Reform Leader Reveals Sordid
Implications of LP Membership Pledge." (TK

No wonder you haven't yet taken this pledge -- you just expressed interest
in committing a mild form of fraud (which is itself a form of force
initiation).  A non-fraudulent title would instead say: "implications of the
radical interpretation of the LP Membership Pledge".  Wow, I didn't think
this exercise would pay such immediate dividends in clarifying where various
radicals stand with respect to initiation of force. :-)

There is still time to become the world's first 100/100/100 LP radical.
Who's got next?  Marc?

Reply via email to