Quoth Brian Holtz:

-----
(We can negotiate over the details of the pledge if necessary, but
each element of it follows straightforwardly from an absolute
commitment to never endorse the initiation of force.)
-----

I'll be hitting each point of your proposed pledge from my own
perspective, but I'll also point out which points do not, in fact,
"follow straightforwardly from an absolute commitment to never endorse
the initiation of force."

-----
I do not -- and will never -- advocate, practice or abet the
initiation of force -- by any person, group, or institution, through
any law, regulation, or practice -- for political or social goals.
-----

I'm trying to figure out here why you throw in the "and will never"
bit, and the best I can come up with is that you think it in some way
differentiates your pledge from the LP's membership certification. It
doesn't. The party trusts each member to police him or her self, but
the obvious corollary to the certification is that if at any time it
ceases to describe one's views, one should withdraw one'[s endorsement
of it and leave the party.


-----
If I am ever a candidate for political office:

*       I will publicly advocate immediate repeal of all laws that in any
way authorize or tolerate the initiation of force.
-----

This does not "follow straightforwardly from an absolute commitment to
never endorse the initiation of force." Not advocating immediate
repeal of Law X is not an endorsement of Law X or a call for its
perpetuation.

-----
*       I will never commit to any particular order of destatization, for
that would be construed as endorsing the continuation of statism and
the violation of rights.
-----

This one's a bit slippery. I have no problem with "committing to a
particular order of destatization" by proposing some kind of
sequential program. I would not, however, stand in the way of some
part of that program being implemented ahead of my schedule.

I don't think the difference between "we can ONLY reach freedom in the
following order: A, B, C -- and if anyone tries to do C before A, I
will oppose them" and "hey, let's try to reach freedom by doing A,
then B, then C" is especially subtle.

Furthermore, the above does not "follow straightforwardly from an
absolute commitment to never endorse the initiation of force." The
fact that someone might construe a particular proposed sequence as, at
any given point, an endorsement of perpetuating the non-liberty status
quo obtaining in areas that sequence has not yet reached, is
irrelevant to whether or not it is, in fact, such an endorsement.

-----
*       I will refuse to accept any salary financed by coercive taxation.
-----

Once again, this not only does not "follow straightforwardly from an
absolute commitment to never endorse the initiation of force," it
doesn't even follow non-straightforwardly. Unless you have information
that I don't have pertaining to how the salaries paid to public
officials, government employees and contractors, etc. are refunded to
the taxpayers if uncollected by those officials, employees,
contractors, etc., then there's no initiation of force involved in
accepting such a salary. The force was initiated when the money was
stolen, not when it is disbursed.

-----
*       I will refuse any funding of my campaign financed by coercive taxation.
-----

See above.

-----
*       I will refuse any media access granted by coercive equal-time or
fairness laws.
-----

I can endorse that. If the Fairness Doctrine or some other legal
requirement to provide me as a candidate with media existed, I would:

a) Ask the media outlet for the time/space and make clear that if they
expressed a preference not to give it to me, I would not invoke said
legal requirement.

b) Offer to pay "the going rate" even if they were required to offer
the time/space gratis, or to contribute an equal amount to a charity
of their choice in lieu of said payment at their option.

-----
*       I will publicly declare my mental reservation to any oath or
affirmation to preserve, protect, or defend any Constitution insofar
as it authorizes the initiation of force.
-----

I am unaware of any situation in which preserving, protecting or
defending any Constitution would require the initiation of force.

-----
If I ever hold executive office:
 
*       I will use whatever authority I can to grant full amnesty and
pardons to anyone and everyone ever accused or convicted of tax
evasion, any other victimless crime, or self-defense against an agent
of the State or any other aggressor.
-----

Once again, I can agree to that, even though it does not "follow
straightforwardly from an absolute commitment to never endorse the
initiation of force." Failure to correct all past initiation of force
by others in no way constitutes a breach of an agreement not to
endorse the initiation of force.

-----
*       I will use whatever authority I can to veto, nullify, or cancel any
law that in any way authorizes or tolerates the initiation of force.
-----

Yes.

-----
*       I will refuse to authorize or commit any initiation of force for any
reason.
-----

Yes.

-----
*       I will refuse to expend any funds derived in any significant part by
coercive taxation, except to return them to taxation victims in the
exact amounts of their victimization.
-----

Interesting, but not required by a pledge "to never endorse the
initiation of force."

-----
If I ever hold legislative office:

*       I will never vote for any bill or amendment containing any provision
or language that authorizes or tolerates the initiation of force.

Depends on what you mean by "tolerate." If you mean "explicitly
tolerate," i.e. "Pursuant to Subsection 556 of this bill, we declare
our tolerance of chattel slavery," then sure, I can sign on to the
above. If you mean that every bill must include explicit
non-toleration of every possible initiation of force in order to be
acceptable, then you're just being silly.

-----
*       I will vote for bills falling short of outright repeal of
force-initiating laws only if they straightforwardly amend such laws
to strictly reduce their scope or effect without reiterating any
language authorizing or tolerating the initiation of force.
-----

Nice try. If the bill already exists, then voting for a version of it
to which all amendments reduce the scope/effect is not voting for the
initiation of force -- since that initiation has already occurred and
would continue unabated with or without my vote. Vote for the amended
version would be a pure-d, 100% anti-force-initiation vote.

-----
*       I will leave it to statist legislators to "reform" their
> force-initiating laws by trading off force initiations of different
kinds or with different victims, and will never taint the cause of
liberty by voting for any such "reform".
-----

Fuckin' A Skippy!

-----
*       I will never vote to confirm the nomination to political office of
anyone who does not take this pledge.
-----

If I was taking this pledge (I'm not), yes, I would commit to that.

-----
*       I will always vote for the impeachment and removal of any
officeholder who does not follow this pledge.
-----

Sure.

-----
If I ever hold judicial office: 
 
*       I will strike down any law I can that in any way authorizes or
tolerates the initiation of force.
-----

The key there being "I can." If the powers of the office include the
power to strike down laws for that reason, yes, I would do so.

-----
*       I will dismiss any case brought before me against anyone and
everyone charged with the pardonable "crimes" listed above.
-----

If by "the pardonable 'crimes' listed above" you mean violations of
the laws I just said I'd strike down if legitimately empowered to do
so, of course.

 
-----
As a citizen:
 
*       I will never vote for any candidate who does not take this pledge.
-----

-----
*       I will write in "No 1st Force" in any race in which there is no
candidate who takes this pledge.
-----

Unlikely, and not required by a pledge not to initiate force. I could
just as easily write in NOTA, write in myself, or just cast no vote in
that race.

-----
*       I will never vote for a ballot measure that in any way authorizes or
tolerates the initiation of force.
-----

Works for me.

-----
*       I will vote for ballot measures falling short of outright repeal of
force-initiating laws only if they straightforwardly amend such laws
to strictly reduce their scope or effect without reiterating any
language authorizing or tolerating the initiation of force.
-----

As noted above, the requirement has no basis in reality.

-----
*       I will never vote on a grand jury to indict anyone of the pardonable
"crimes" listed above.
*       I will never vote on a jury to convict anyone of the pardonable
"crimes" listed above.
-----

Agreed.

-----
*       I will never accept any employment financed in any significant part
by coercive taxation.
*       I will never accept any payments financed in any significant part by
coercive taxation, except insofar as they constitute repayment of
funds previously taxed from me.
-----

See above. I'll take this pledge after you show me that declining such
employment/payment would result in the initiation of force which
resulted in its availability being reversed.

-----
*       I will never voluntarily participate in the enforcement of any law
that in any way authorizes or tolerates the initiation of force.
-----

Agreed.

-----
As an LP member:
 
*       I will never nominate, endorse, or vote for any candidate for LP
office who does not take this pledge.
-----

Since you've described this pledge as "follow[ing] straightforwardly
from an absolute commitment to never endorse the initiation of force,"
and since that is the summary of the LP's membership certification
pledge, then all possible candidates for LP office (LP membership
being a requirement of said office) have already constructively taken
this pledge and I would have no opportunity to nominate, endorse, or
vote for any candidate who had not. Therefore, this clause is
inapplicable.

-----
*       I will never support or vote for any LP Platform that does not
advocate immediate repeal of all laws that in any way authorize or
tolerate the initiation of force.
*       I will never support or vote for any LP Platform that does not
advocate full amnesty and pardons to anyone and everyone ever accused
or convicted of tax evasion, any other victimless crime, or
self-defense against an agent of the State or any other aggressor.
-----

The above does not "follow straightforwardly from an absolute
commitment to never endorse the initiation of force." Frankly, I don't
know whether I'm appalled that you think the LP's member certification
implies all these things, or that you continue to oppose them having
certified in writing that you support them.

Regards,
Tom Knapp

Reply via email to