Posted by: Ulil Abshar-Abdalla E-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Sat Jan 27, 2007 7:31 pm (PST)
Barack Obama difitnah oleh Fox News baru-baru ini: dia "dituduh" pernah sekolah di SD Islam yang orientasinya radikal waktu kecil di Jakarta dulu, seperti disinggung dalam berita yang saya kirim di bawah ini. Fox News jelas media sekuler. Tapi, anehnya, cara2 dia yang memakai fitnah seperti ini juga dilakukan oleh banyak media yang konon "Islami" di Jakarta. Sementara itu, fitnah yang beredar lewat internet, sudah tak kepalang tanggung jumlahnya. Memang, watak manusia memang suka fitnah, tampaknya. Hanya saja, ada dua jenis fitnah: fitnah dengan motivasi agama, dan fitnah dengan motifasi sekuler. Tapi, dua-duanya tetap saja fitnah. Ulil Ulil Abshar-Abdalla Department of Religion Boston Universit --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Lessons for Media in Obama Case By DAVID BAUDER AP Television Writer NEW YORK, January 27 (AP) - U.S. Sen. Barack Obama hardly could have anticipated that the first minor media crisis of his presidential bid would involve where he went to school at age 7. The Illinois Democrat's welcome into the world of modern campaign coverage last week offers lessons for both candidates and reporters on the marathon run until November 2008. And it's undoubtedly a sign of things to come. Chances are "about 100 percent" that a candidate will be ruined by a story that he or she hasn't anticipated, said ABC News political reporter Jake Tapper. Stories seemingly trivial or even untrue will appear instantly and reverberate madly through the media. Candidates most skillful in anticipating them and reacting swiftly will have a big advantage. A magazine article's charge that Obama had attended a radical Islamic school while living in Indonesia as a boy was spread on blogs and, most prominently, on Fox News Channel. Other news organizations sent reporters who learned the school in Jakarta was public and secular and has long accepted students of all faiths. CNN's Anderson Cooper seemed to relish sticking the knife in a rival. "That's the difference between talking about news and reporting it," he said. "You send a reporter, check the facts and you decide at home." CNN had time to do that because it wasn't a hard news story, said Sam Feist, the network's political director. "One of the things that's dangerous about a presidential campaign when it comes to the facts is the echo chamber, where one news organization reports a story and it's not true, and one outlet picks it up, another picks it up and another," Feist said. "Before long the public assumes that it's true even when it's not." Tapper wrote about the story, with the Obama campaign's denials, on his blog when it first surfaced. But like CNN, it didn't appear on the air at ABC until after a reporter had gone to Jakarta. Whether the same caution would have held a year later, if the charges had surfaced in the few days between the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary, is an open question. "A long and protracted campaign like we're going to see means you're going to have long periods with not much news and news outlets are going to want to fill the void," said Tom Rosenstiel, a former political reporter for the Los Angeles Times and now director of the Project for Excellence in Journalism. "In some ways, there are more openings for opposition research, dirty tricks, to get into play." Back in 1992, when the story first surfaced about Bill Clinton and his alleged affair with Gennifer Flowers, a reporter asked him about it one day and received a response. Yet the story was left off all three network newscasts that evening. That notion of restraint, of major news organizations taking time to weigh the newsworthiness of these kinds of stories, seems almost impossible to imagine today. Before the Internet's spread, a newsroom used to have only a handful of news sources coming into their computers, said Marty Ryan, political director at Fox News Channel. "Now there are hundreds, thousands," he said. "Many of them have a political agenda and many of them have different standards for what they put on their blogs and their Internet sites. We just have to be real careful about what happens in the future." Being careful about the facts is a lesson drummed into every journalist. But opinion-based talk shows aren't run by journalists. They're a staple of Fox's lineup and spreading around other cable news outlets. "You can't say it's right or wrong, it's just different," Ryan said. "We acknowledge that. We acknowledged the error with the Obama thing and let's just move on." Television quickly magnifies stories that might have been forgotten or not even noticed otherwise, with Howard Dean's scream an infamous example. Remember: Most Americans did not have three cable news networks in their homes until the 2000 campaign. Similarly, it wasn't too long ago that the only Web site political professionals watched carefully was the Drudge Report. Now, there are dozens of political blogs that must be monitored. Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, an expected GOP presidential candidate, has gone out of his way to cultivate relationships with prominent bloggers. He learned their bite earlier this month when a Massachusetts gadfly, Brian Camenker, wrote a lengthy report questioning Romney's conservative qualifications that spread quickly on the Web. Most campaigns have opposition research staff, whose job it is to search for damaging information about an opponent. The smart candidates do aggressive opposition research on themselves, so as not to be surprised by anything. Campaigns are actually less likely now to feed damaging material to mainstream news organizations, Tapper said. The campaigns prefer the blogs. "There are so many ways to get information out to people -- whether or not that information is true," said Elizabeth Wilner, chief of NBC News' political unit. Many Democrats believe that John Kerry's inability to respond quickly to an unanticipated story -- charges by the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth that he didn't deserve his Vietnam War medals -- doomed his 2004 campaign. Swift response is now valued. So is aggressive response. Still, the political whirlwind may not slow down because of the Obama example. "I honestly think that no one is going to be chastened by anything this year," Rosenstiel said. __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
