Me and the TSA

by Bruce Schneier
November 15, 2008

There was a great article from The Atlantic about me helping evade 
airport security. We printed fake boarding passes, explained how 
anyone on the no-fly list could get through security, and brought on 
more liquids than should be allowed.

Kip Hawley, head of the TSA, has responded to the article on his blog.

Unfortunately, there's not really anything to his response. It's 
obvious he doesn't want to admit that they've been checking ID's all 
this time to no purpose whatsoever, so he just emits vague 
generalities like a frightened squid filling the water with ink. Yes, 
some of the stunts in article are silly (who cares if people fly with 
Hezbollah T-shirts?) so that gives him an opportunity to minimize the 
real issues.

Hawley says: "Watch-lists and identity checks are important and 
effective security measures. We identify dozens of terrorist-related 
individuals a week and stop No-Flys regularly with our watch-list 
process."

It is simply impossible that the TSA catches dozens of terrorists 
every week. If it were true, the administration would be trumpeting 
this all over the press -- it would be an amazing success story in 
their war on terrorism. But note that Hawley doesn't exactly say 
that; he calls them "terrorist-related individuals." Which means 
exactly what? People so dangerous they can't be allowed to fly for 
any reason, yet so innocent they can't be arrested -- even under the 
provisions of the Patriot Act.

And if Secretary Chertoff is telling the truth when he says that 
there are only 2,500 people on the no-fly list and fewer than 16,000 
people on the selectee list -- they're the ones that get extra 
screening -- and that most of them live outside the U.S., then it is 
just plain impossible that the TSA identifies "dozens" of these 
people every week. The math just doesn't make sense.

...

http://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram-0811.html#2

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to