January 24, 2009 11:09 AM PST

Saving the Digital Transition

By Gregory L. Rosston and Scott Wallsten
News.com

We're turning over this space today to a guest post from Gregory L. 
Rosston and Scott Wallsten. Rosston is the Deputy Director of the 
Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research and the Public Policy 
program at Stanford University and served as the Deputy Chief Economist 
of the Federal Communications Commission from 1994-1997. Wallsten is 
Vice President for Research and a Senior Fellow at the Technology Policy 
Institute.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-10787_3-10149647-60.html?tag=newsFeaturedBlogArea.0


The outgoing administration and the 110th Congress are leaving an 
impending mess for President Obama and his administration to manage. No, 
not that one. Not that one either.

Less than a month after the inauguration, millions of Americans who 
don't subscribe to cable or satellite services may see nothing but 
static on their screens. The reason is that on February 17 broadcasters 
must stop all analog television transmissions--the only kind that older 
televisions can receive over the air--and continue only digital 
transmissions.

Make no mistake, the digital transition is long overdue and will greatly 
benefit the American people. But this transition will not go nearly as 
smoothly as the political transition has gone unless some steps are 
taken immediately to soften the blow and subsequent uproar.

We already have evidence that the transition may not go well. One smart 
move was that broadcasters in Wilmington, NC agreed to turn off their 
analog signals in September. That test-run allowed the FCC to see what 
might happen. It was not pretty. Despite the relatively substantial 
resources devoted to preparing the city, when broadcasters turned off 
their analog signals, calls poured in to television stations, city 
offices, and even 911 call centers from frustrated and confused residents.

The good news is that the Wilmington transition ended with no major 
calamities and now the freed-up spectrum is available for other more 
valuable uses. But the Wilmington area has fewer than 13,000 households 
that rely on over-the-air broadcast, whereas the entire U.S. has about 
17 million such households. Another 19 million households subscribe to 
cable or satellite but have at least one TV that uses broadcast signals. 
In other words, the small brouhaha in Wilmington will be hugely 
magnified when the entire country makes the switch.

The primary mechanism to prepare citizens for the switch is a $1.5 
billion coupon program intended to subsidize "converter boxes." These 
boxes connect to an antenna and to a TV set and convert the digital 
signal into a form the television can display. Households can, in 
principle, get two $40 coupons from the government to offset the price 
of two boxes. However, demand for coupons has been so intense that the 
program is out of money, prompting cries for more increased subsidies.

The real problem with the coupon program, however, is not that it is too 
small. The problem is that it is ineffective. In recent research one of 
us found that the coupons increased the price of the boxes by almost the 
amount of the coupon. The coupon program therefore primarily subsidizes 
retailers, not consumers.

This result is not surprising. With a $40 coupon, you don't care whether 
the box costs $0 or $40, since you pay nothing either way. Retailers 
thus have little incentive to price a box at less than $40.

Still, the program's current lack of funds reflects some good news. 
First, it means that many people have gone out to purchase boxes and are 
likely to be ready for the switch. Second, the shortage has itself 
created news and may increase awareness, causing more people to make the 
necessary preparations (buy a converter box, buy a new television, 
subscribe to cable or satellite, or pick up a book). The bad news is 
that lack of coupons may cause some people not to acquire a converter box.

Congress will probably top up the coupon program for fear of being 
accused of not responding to this mini-crisis, but that won't be of much 
help to consumers, and no help to those who will need it the most, such 
as elderly people who may have no idea how to connect and configure a 
converter box (see the YouTube video, "Digital TV transition (for the 
Elderly)").

What can be done in the next few weeks, aside from expanding the coupon 
program? It's too late for a comprehensive new plan, but the FCC could 
still buy time to reduce 911 calls and to minimize the confusion from 
people suddenly seeing "snow" on their screens.

An increasingly popular proposal is to delay the transition by several 
months. That may avoid trouble in February, but will probably only put 
off the pain rather than eliminate it. The proposal, however, has the 
kernel of the right solution.

In particular, the FCC could require stations to continue their analog 
transmissions for two weeks in order to continuously broadcast a simple 
full-screen message that reads and also says aloud, "Your television 
needs a digital converter box. For more information, call 1-888-225-5322 
(TTY: 1-888-835-5322) or visit: www.DTV.gov."

Congress, in fact, gave the FCC the ability to make this happen under 
the "Analog Nightlight Act." So far, though, the FCC has authorized only 
a handful of stations to run this "nightlight" service because of 
interference concerns. The FCC could immediately expand the program by 
loosening restrictions on which stations can participate and by not 
requiring them to apply for eligibility.

This plan would not be free. Not all analog signals have to shut down to 
accommodate other uses, and those station owners could be subsidized a 
small amount to maintain the broadcast. A larger expense would involve 
compensating the wireless providers who paid $19 billion for this 
spectrum to wait for two weeks before beginning their transmissions. A 
two-week delay probably would not be a big burden on the providers as 
they have yet to deploy systems fully and have not sold any relevant 
devices to consumers.

Had the Commission and Congress better thought through the problems 
earlier, they could have mandated such broadcasts for at least one week 
prior to the analog shutdown. They could also have had monthly test 
markets like Wilmington, NC. We would then have had at least 10 fully 
functioning digital markets and would have learned many more lessons 
about the transition.

By March 19, 2009, hopefully the only March Madness will be on the court 
and in the living rooms of households watching through televisions 
equipped for the digital age. The benefits to consumers from the switch 
are far too great to be derailed by the poor planning of the past two 
years and short-term political uproar. Use of the returned television 
spectrum and spaces between the digital channels promises to increase 
the quality and reliability of voice, data andvideo service for wireless 
consumers. We cannot let poor planning delay the benefits of that true 
digital transition.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to