January 25, 2009

Cellphones as Credit Cards? Americans Must Wait
By LESLIE BERLIN
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/25/business/25proto.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


IMAGINE a technology that lets you pay for products just by waving your 
cellphone over a reader.

The technology exists, and, in fact, people in Japan have been using it 
for the last five years to pay for everything from train tickets to 
groceries to candy in vending machines. And in small-scale trials around 
the world, including in Atlanta, New York and the San Francisco Bay 
Area, nearly everyone has liked using this form of payment.

But consumers in the United States won’t be able to wave and pay with 
their cellphones anytime soon: The myriad companies that must work 
together to give the technology to the masses have yet to agree on how 
to split the resulting revenue.

“In Japan it was easier,” explains Gerhard Romen, director for corporate 
business development at Nokia. “It was just the major guys saying, ‘This 
is how it will be.’ ” A single carrier, NTT DoCoMo, accounted for more 
than half the Japanese market at the time the system was rolled out and 
thus had significant leverage with financial institutions and handset 
manufacturers.

This is not the case in the United States. For such payments to work 
here, cellphone manufacturers, carriers, financial institutions and 
retailers must all play roles. There also must be some sort of 
intermediary that is trusted by both the financial institutions and the 
carriers to activate the virtual credit cards inside the phone.

One problem is that anyone using a credit card inside a cellphone is 
simultaneously a customer of the financial institution and of the 
carrier. “At the end of the day, the question is, ‘Who pays whom and how 
much?’” Mr. Romen says. “The carriers and the banks need to get their 
act together on payment.” He adds that the back-and-forth is a necessary 
step in the creation of a complex system.

Short-range technology, called N.F.C., for Near Field Communication, 
enables a phone to talk to an electronic reader. It is already in 
widespread use — though, outside Japan, often not in phones.

In London, for example, the technology is embedded in the “Oyster” cards 
used to access the transportation system. The technology is also used in 
credit cards like payWave from Visa and PayPass from MasterCard that are 
waved over readers, rather than swiped through them.

For a phone, the technology to store account information securely is 
advanced enough so that several different virtual cards can be placed 
inside the phone; users can select an account by using the screen.

Account information can be embedded in the telephone or on a SIM card or 
microSD card, but no call over a network is needed to send the data. 
Proximity is the key: for the payment to work, the phone needs to be 
within a few centimeters of the reader.

The idea of equipping a cellphone with virtual credit cards worries some 
people; phones, after all, are easily lost or stolen. But Simon Pugh, 
group head of the mobile payments group at MasterCard Worldwide, said 
that if the phone were lost, the consumer could call the bank — using 
another phone, of course — to disable the account. He also said that 
consumers could choose to protect the payment part of their phone with 
an access code, but he added that the payment would also be secure even 
without such measures.

The risk of account fraud from mobile payments is “small,” according to 
Kevin Fu, an assistant professor of computer science at the University 
of Massachusetts, Amherst, who in 2006 uncovered several security holes 
in credit cards that are waved rather than swiped. Credit-card companies 
say that these problems have been fixed.

Mr. Fu is more concerned about privacy. He says that it may be possible 
to get personal information, like a person’s name, from credit-card 
account data on a mobile phone. Nonetheless, he predicts that with time, 
“these N.F.C. phones will become one of the best ways to do mobile 
payments.”

It is almost certain that mobile-phone payments will eventually come to 
the United States. After all, the technology promises something for 
everyone involved: Credit-card companies would have a new way to attract 
and keep customers and would save money by no longer sending cards 
through the mail. Carriers would enjoy another source of revenue. 
Retailers would benefit from a faster checkout process, and may find 
that people buy more when they pay with their phones.

And according to Joanne Trout, vice president of worldwide 
communications for MasterCard Worldwide, there will not be an additional 
fee for consumers to use credit cards on their phones.

Consumers, too, would probably like using their cellphone credit cards, 
if wave-and-pay were secure and widely available. It may be another 
instance of the phenomenon, so common in technology, of not knowing we 
want something until we have it. “People really do like it,” said Key 
Pousttchi, head of the Wi-mobile research group at the University of 
Augsburg in Germany. “It is easy. It is convenient. It helps you.”

The group has surveyed thousands of people who have participated in 
mobile-phone trials around the world.

Mr. Pousttchi says he expects that by 2012, most phones will contain the 
N.F.C. technology that makes wave-and-pay possible. But he cautions that 
this doesn’t necessarily mean that Americans will be paying with their 
cellphones in three years. For that to happen, all the players will have 
to work together to define standards, determine revenue-sharing, expand 
the network of electronic readers and think through the other parts of 
what he calls “this 2,000-piece puzzle.”

The NFC Forum, an industry association based in Wakefield, Mass., whose 
150 members include manufacturers, carriers and financial institutions, 
is a good start. Mr. Romen and Mr. Pugh are both vice chairmen of the group.

Nonetheless, Mr. Pousttchi warns, “it is completely possible nothing 
will happen in mobile payments in the next five years if everybody keeps 
thinking only about their own piece of the puzzle.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to