JANUARY 30, 2009

Telecoms Say Web Funding For Unserved Falls Short

By AMOL SHARMA
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123326956344630723.html


The funding that Congress is likely to set aside for build-outs of 
high-speed Internet in its economic-stimulus package falls short of what 
service providers say is required to reach rural and unserved areas, based 
on initial cost estimates by several companies.

A trade group representing midsize telecom providers with 27 million 
customers says its members alone would require $6 billion to $6.5 billion 
to reach about 3.6 million homes in their territories that don't have 
high-speed Internet access.

That includes Qwest Communications International Inc., which says its rural 
build-out would cost $3 billion, but doesn't include estimates from bigger 
providers such as AT&T Inc. and Verizon Communications Inc., or any cable 
companies.

The House passed a stimulus bill Wednesday that would include $6 billion in 
broadband grants. They could be used not just for first-time deployments in 
unserved areas but also for next-generation upgrades to existing networks. 
Legislation moving through the Senate includes a $9 billion grant program.

Some public-interest groups had argued for a broadband stimulus in the tens 
of billions of dollars. Advocates say broadband deployment is critical to 
the competitiveness of the U.S. economy. The U.S. has slipped to 15th place 
from fourth since 2001 in broadband penetration, according to the 
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

There are no precise data on the number of unserved broadband households in 
the U.S., but a consumer survey by the Pew Internet Project found there 
were about 10 million.

Rep. Rick Boucher, a Virginia Democrat who heads the House subcommittee on 
technology and the Internet, said other federal programs for rural 
broadband have shown that even a modest amount of grant money, used 
efficiently, can have an impact.

"I'm not sure the claim can be made that this legislation will bring 
broadband to every last person in America," he said "But if we can improve 
the reach of broadband, that would be a major advancement."

The main goal of the recovery package is job creation. Qwest says that by 
bringing Internet service to towns like Tombstone, Ariz., and Warm Springs, 
Ore., it could create tens of thousands of jobs, from network engineers to 
trench diggers who lay broadband lines in the ground. Qwest, which serves 
14 states in the West and Midwest, says it is prepared to roll out digital 
subscriber line, or DSL, service with download speeds of 7 megabits per 
second, faster than the 5-megabit standard the House and Senate are likely 
to mandate.

The Independent Telephone and Telecommunications Alliance, the group of 
mid-tier phone companies, said its cost estimate was predicated on a slower 
speed of 1.5 megabits per second, which would be easier for most of its 
members to offer. Meeting the higher standard in the legislation would make 
rollouts more costly, said Curt Stamp, the group's president.

Gene Kimmelman, vice president of federal policy at Consumers Union, said 
it isn't surprising that there isn't an enormous amount of broadband 
funding in legislation whose main purpose is to stimulate the economy. "I'm 
not displeased at the size of the investment, he said. "Given the other 
things consumers need, I don't think broadband was as important."

Cable providers have taken issue with the standard the Senate bill uses for 
a next-generation service -- one with download speeds of 100 megabits per 
second and upload speeds of 20 megabits per second -- which they say would 
favor the fiber-optic networks used by Verizon, according to people close 
to the cable industry. Verizon declined to comment.

Cable providers also want to see money directed mainly at unserved areas. 
"Most of the monies people are talking about in terms of the broadband 
stimulus package would be needed just to solve that problem," said Kyle 
McSlarrow, president and chief executive of the National Cable and 
Telecommunications Association.

The Senate bill also includes limited tax credits -- 20% of investments in 
unserved areas and 20% of investments in next-generation services in 
underserved markets, which are defined essentially as low-income areas. 
Phone companies say these incentives aren't big enough to attract 
investment by Internet service providers. They are pushing for credits in 
unserved areas closer to 50%. The Senate Finance Committee estimated the 
cost of the tax credits to the government at just $110 million over 10 years.

"This is about deploying broadband in small-town America, where the 
economics do not now -- and will not in the foreseeable future -- justify 
the expenditure for us," said Steve Davis, senior vice president of public 
policy at Qwest.


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to