January 29, 2009, 05:17 PM EST

How the Senate and House Differ on Broadband Spending

By Amy Schatz
Wall Street Journal

http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2009/01/29/how-the-senate-and-house-differ-on-broadband-spending/?mod=rss_WSJBlog?mod=


Differences between the two broadband stimulus proposals working their way 
through Congress could take a little while to work out, but details of the 
plans that have popped up this week offer a map of where things might end up.

The House and Senate haven't agreed on much about the broadband stimulus so 
far, neither the cost ($6 billion in the House, $9 billion in the Senate) 
nor Internet speeds ("advanced broadband" in the House clocks in at 45mbps, 
while the Senate says "next-generation" broadband is 100 mpbs).

Cable operators aren't thrilled about language in the House and Senate 
bills, which sets aside grant money for broadband providers who can provide 
100 mbps service, since that would tend to favor phone companies installing 
fiber-to-the-home service.

"We all want faster speeds. What's the appropriate role of providing 
incentives for next-generation architecture?" asked Kyle McSlarrow, head of 
the National Cable & Telecommunications Association, in a YouTube video 
posted on the lobbying group's Web site Thursday.

House lawmakers would hand out $6 billion in broadband grants. Half would 
be given out by the U.S. Department of Agriculture without speed 
requirements, although 75% of the money has to be used in "rural area(s) 
without sufficient access to high-speed broadband service."

A quarter of the grant money handed out by the Commerce Department would be 
for "basic" broadband service (a.k.a 5 mbps download/1 mbps upload) to 
"un-served" areas while the rest would go for "advanced" broadband service 
(a.k.a 45 mbps/15 mbps) in "underserved" areas. Wireless providers would 
need to offer Internet service with a download speed of at least 3 mbps and 
upload of 1 mbps.

The House would leave it up to the FCC to decide how to define un-served 
and underserved areas.

Senators want $9 billion in broadband, half of which would be set aside for 
providing service in rural areas. The Senate Finance Committee tacked on 
limited tax credits of 10% or 20% to providers offering "current 
generation" (a.k.a. 5 mbps/1 mbps) service in rural areas and 20% credit 
for "next generation" (a.k.a. 100 mbps/20mbps) service in rural or 
low-income areas. The tax credits are relatively small, estimated to cost 
about $110 million over 10 years.

Open access, or net neutrality, conditions could be a major sticking point 
for phone and cable companies, which don't want significant government 
constraints on their network management practices. Right now, companies are 
concerned about how "open access" might be defined in the legislation.

In the House, lawmakers say the FCC would be required to define "open 
access" within 45 days of the legislation's passage. Senate lawmakers say 
their grants would be dependent on "interconnection and nondiscrimination 
requirements," although they spell out what that means.

The broadband spending would also fall on the long-term side of benefits 
which may came from the economic stimulus plan.

The Congressional Budget Office said Wednesday that much of the spending on 
broadband wouldn't really have much of an impact on consumers for several 
years. It could take "up to five to seven years" to finish some projects 
funded by the $2.8 billion handed out by the Agriculture Department's rural 
development broadband program.


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to