MARCH 26, 2009

The Internet Industry Is on a Cloud -- Whatever That May Mean

By GEOFFREY A. FOWLER and BEN WORTHEN
Wall Street Journal

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123802623665542725.html


Ever since Google Inc. Chief Executive Eric Schmidt publicly uttered the 
term "cloud computing" in 2006, a storm has been gathering over Silicon Valley.

Companies across the technology industry are jockeying to associate 
themselves with clouds. Amazon.com Inc., better known for peddling books 
online, began selling an Elastic Compute Cloud service in 2006 for 
programmers to rent Amazon's giant computers. Juniper Networks Inc., which 
makes gear for transmitting data, dubbed its latest project Stratus. Yahoo 
Inc., Intel Corp. and a handful of others recently launched a research 
program called OpenCirrus.

While almost everybody in the tech industry seems to have a cloud-themed 
project, few agree on the term's definition.

"I have no idea what anyone is talking about," said Oracle Corp. Chief 
Executive Larry Ellison, when talking about cloud computing at a financial 
analyst conference in September. "It's really just complete gibberish. What 
is it?" He added: "When is this idiocy going to stop?"

In its broadest sense, cloud computing describes something apparent to 
anybody who uses the Internet: Information is stored and processed on 
computers somewhere else -- "in the clouds" -- and brought back to your screen.

But no two clouds, apparently, are alike. A company's backroom mass of 
servers and switches is cloudlike. So are social-networking sites like 
Facebook Inc., or the act of buying a book on Amazon. Some clouds, like 
Google's email service, Gmail, are public. Others, like corporate networks, 
are closed to outsiders.

Part of the problem, say observers, is that the tech industry has become 
bogged down in jargon. Companies have long pushed the likes of 
"network-distributed parallel processing," often packaged as "solutions" 
that are "end-to-end" and "scalable." Cloud sounds much nicer.

"What took them so long? Cloud-based services seem much easier to grasp 
than 'Application Service Provision.' ASP -- who came up with that?" says 
Michael Litchfield, a creative director at Omnicom Group's Doremus, a 
communications firm that specializes in technology and financial topics. 
"The cloud is accessible. It may, in fact, be brilliant."

And possibly overused, says Hewlett-Packard Co. executive Russ Daniels. He 
says H-P, a backer of OpenCirrus, tries to use the catchphrase only when 
appropriate. "There is so much pressure to just go with the flow and wrap 
everything up in this single word," said Mr. Daniels, H-P's vice president 
and chief technology officer of Cloud Services Strategy.

Despite its recent surge in popularity, the cloud is among the oldest 
pieces of computer jargon, says Alex Bochannek, a curator at the Computer 
History Museum in Mountain View, Calif. For decades, engineers drew them in 
schematic diagrams to show where their own network joins another whose 
inner workings are unknown or irrelevant. "You symbolize that with a cloud, 
or some amorphous shape," says Mr. Bochannek.

By the late 1990s, clouds had become the go-to metaphor for all things 
Internet. The PowerPoint set used cloud icons in their presentations, at 
times referring to the Internet simply as "the cloud." New shades of 
meaning emerged over the past decade as Google and other Internet companies 
created software that could run simultaneously on multiple servers -- 
hence, operate in a "cloud."

At a 2006 conference, Google's Mr. Schmidt delivered his public description 
of the emerging model. He added: "I don't think people have really 
understood how big this opportunity really is."

Estimates, in fact, vary wildly. Research firm IDC predicts cloud computing 
will reach $42 billion in 2012. (It defines the segment as "an emerging IT 
development, deployment and delivery model, enabling real-time delivery of 
products, services and solutions over the Internet.") Gartner Inc. projects 
world-wide cloud-services revenue will rise 21.3% in 2009 to $56.3 billion. 
(Gartner calls it "a style of computing where scalable and elastic 
IT-enabled capabilities are provided 'as a service' to external customers 
using Internet technologies"; its forecast includes online advertising.) 
Merrill Lynch last year estimated cloud-computing revenues would reach $160 
billion in 2011. (Merrill declined to provide a copy of its report.)

Analyst Frank Gillett of Forrester Research, which doesn't currently 
measure the cloud market, says makers of existing technologies -- "grid 
computing," "virtualization" -- are attempting to co-opt the word. Mr. 
Gillett calls this process "cloud washing."

Marc Benioff, CEO of online business software company Salesforce.com Inc., 
cottoned on to the term in December 2007. That was when he read a magazine 
article that dubbed Google and Amazon cloud-computing leaders.

"We were a laggard in using that name," Mr. Benioff says. For years, 
Salesforce had described its offerings in terms of "enterprise applications 
as online services," "online customer relationship management" and 
"on-demand business services." For his next presentation, Mr. Benioff added 
two slides on "cloud computing" and berated his staff for not getting 
Salesforce mentioned in the magazine.

"I couldn't believe how worked up he was about the term," says Tien Tzou, 
Salesforce's chief strategist at the time. "We had tried all sorts of terms 
to get the marketplace to understand what we were doing. Cloud computing 
was going to be the one that would stick," says Mr. Tzou, who went on to 
found Zuora Inc., a cloud-computing company.

In November, Salesforce held a conference that one of its speakers dubbed 
the "Woodstock of cloud computing." It hired people to stand outside a 
convention center in San Francisco, wearing white puffy jackets and holding 
oversized cloud balloons. Inside, projectors painted a digital sky on the 
ceiling. The Rolling Stones'"Get Off of My Cloud" blared on the sound system.

In the full fiscal year since Salesforce started using the term cloud 
computing, its revenue grew 44%. "I think it's the most powerful term in 
the industry," Mr. Benioff says.

Cloud-themed puns have since multiplied, generating even a few seemingly 
contradictory uses. Sun Microsystems Inc. recently unveiled a product 
called the "Sun Cloud." Microsoft Corp. sells a cloud service called 
"Azure," which the dictionary defines as a cloudless sky. Apple Inc., of 
course, is doing its own thing: Its new Mobile Me product is branded not 
with the word cloud, but with an image of one.

Dell Inc. applied to trademark the term cloud computing last year. The U.S. 
Patent and Trademark Office initially approved the application. But it 
changed its mind in response to an outburst of criticism, including from 
bloggers incensed that the term could fall under one company's control.

A Dell spokesman says the trademark was intended only to cover "the design 
of computer hardware for use in data centers." He adds that the computer 
maker has no plans to pursue the issue further.

Historian Mr. Bochannek says that cloud computing could join past tech 
terms -- "cyberspace," "Web 2.0" -- that have gone from boom to bust. "The 
problem isn't so much the term," he says, "but the extended usage of it to 
subsume other things."

For some, clouds are already empty puffery. "We've redefined cloud 
computing to include everything that we already do," Mr. Ellison said at 
the analyst conference in September. "I can't think of anything that isn't 
cloud computing with all of these announcements. The computer industry is 
the only industry that is more fashion-driven than women's fashion."

Still, Mr. Ellison acknowledged he was powerless: Oracle, too, would 
probably start using the label. Last week in an earnings call, Mr. Ellison 
made good: He described Oracle's upcoming software as "cloud-computing ready."


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to