http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/30/opinion/30iht-edmorozov.html

OP-ED CONTRIBUTOR
Propaganda.com

By EVGENY MOROZOV
March 30, 2009

This year's report on "enemies of the Internet" prepared by Reporters 
Without Borders, the international press advocacy group, paints a 
very gloomy picture for the freedom of expression on the Web. It 
finds that many governments have stepped up their attacks on the 
Internet, harassing bloggers and making it harder to express 
dissenting opinions online.
These are very disturbing trends. But identifying "Internet enemies" 
only on the basis of censorship and intimidation, as Reporters 
Without Borders has done, obfuscates the fact that these are only two 
components of a more comprehensive and multi-pronged approach that 
authoritarian governments have developed to diffuse the subversive 
potential of online communications.
Many of these governments have honed their Internet strategies beyond 
censorship and are employing more subtle (and harder to detect) ways 
of controlling dissent, often by planting their own messages on the 
Web and presenting them as independent opinion.
Their actions are often informed by the art of online "astroturfing," 
a technique also popular with modern corporations and PR firms. While 
companies use it to engineer buzz around products and events, 
governments are using it to create the appearance of broad popular 
support for their ideology.
Their ultimate ambition may be to transform the Internet into a 
"spinternet," the vast and mostly anonymous areas of cyberspace under 
indirect government jurisdiction. The spinternet strategy could be 
more effective than censorship - while there are a plenty of ways to 
access blocked Web sites, we do not yet have the means to distinguish 
spin from independent comment.
In China, the spinternet is being built by the "50 cent party," a 
loose online squad of tech-savvy operators loyal to the government 
who are paid to troll the Internet, find dissenting views and leave 
anonymous comments to steer all discussions in more "harmonious" 
directions. The "50 cents" in the name stands for their meager pay 
rates.
Plenty of local technology companies are also eager to help the 
government with various data-mining programs that identify dissenting 
views early and dispatch "50 cent party" operators to steer the 
discussion away from an antigovernment direction.
In Iran, the Revolutionary Guards recently announced their ambition 
to build their own spinternet by launching 10,000 blogs for the 
Basij, a paramilitary force under the Guards. This comes at a time 
when the Internet has become a major force in exposing corruption in 
the highest ranks of the Iranian leadership.
The Russian government may have found an even more ingenious way of 
suppressing the Internet's democratizing potential: cost. Many 
Internet users in Russia are still billed on the basis of the 
frequency and duration of their browsing sessions, and the 
state-owned All-Russia State Television and Radio Company has floated 
the idea of building a "social Internet," where users would pay 
nothing for state-approved Web sites.
Such an approach is already being tested in Belarus, where Internet 
users can browse the government's favored mouthpiece, "Belarus 
Today," for free - that is, without paying their ISPs for Internet 
traffic, as they must for the country's few independent media outlets.
The rise of the spinternet suggests that the threats that the 
Internet poses to authoritarian regimes are far from unambiguous; 
some of these governments have turned quite adept at exploiting it 
for their own purposes.
So while it's important to continue documenting the direct repression 
of online journalists and bloggers, as organizations like Reporters 
Without Borders are doing, it is important to remember that there are 
other ways to qualify as an "enemy of the Internet."

Copyright 2009
***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to