http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/29/opinion/29pubed.html


THE PUBLIC EDITOR
No Comment. But You Didn't Hear It From Me.

By CLARK HOYT
March 29, 2009

AT the ceremony where he announced a new drug czar this month, Vice 
President Joseph Biden would not take questions from reporters, but 
before he arrived, a press aide explained why the post was no longer 
a cabinet-level position. It was not necessary, the aide said, 
because the vice president had more than 30 years of experience in 
drug policy and the czar would have access to him and the president.

The young man said reporters could attribute the comment to "an 
administration official," which The Times dutifully did on its Web 
site. Mark Leibovich, a Times reporter, said he asked the aide - who, 
after all, is paid to deal with the news media - "Why can't I quote 
you by name? He said, 'I'm not authorized to speak.' I said, 
'Really?' He said, 'Sorry, that's just the way we do it.' "

Washington, where I have reported and edited (and used my share of 
unnamed sources) for the better part of the last 40 years, is a city 
steeped in the culture of anonymity. Official spokesmen have been 
known to go on background - meaning they cannot be quoted by name - 
to say they will have no comment. Junior press assistants, political 
operatives, Congressional staffers, midlevel bureaucrats, military 
and intelligence officers, cabinet secretaries, and sometimes even 
presidents refuse to be identified for many reasons: all glory is 
supposed to go to the boss; they disagree with the boss and are 
afraid of getting fired; they are talking about classified 
information and could be prosecuted; they want to promote a policy, 
or kill it, by getting it out before it is officially announced; they 
believe the public has a right to know about something that is being 
suppressed.

Some, said Thom Shanker, who covers the Pentagon, just "want us to be 
right." And some, said Jill Abramson, the managing editor for news, 
know that in Washington, "speaking the plain truth can get you in 
trouble."

Some anonymous sources are what Richard Stevenson, a deputy 
Washington bureau chief, calls "human press releases." The Times, The 
Washington Post and USA Today, all citing unnamed sources, carried 
similar front-page stories on Friday revealing that President Obama 
would announce a plan to send 4,000 more troops to Afghanistan. But 
sometimes a story requires painstaking efforts to get bits of 
information from many sources.

Anonymous sources are necessary for some of the most important 
reporting The Times does from Washington, but they also cheapen the 
currency when they creep into stories casually. Times reporters face 
a daily judgment: How critical is information that sources will 
impart only if promised that they will not be identified? So critical 
that it is worth another tug at the fraying bond of trust between the 
news media and the public?

Times reporters and editors say they put a lot of care into the 
decisions. Here is how they wound up making them in three recent 
examples - one in which anonymous sources were vital and 
well-explained, one in which anonymity was a close call, and one in 
which anonymous quotes were removed before publication.

*

The paper's top story last Thursday reported that operatives from 
Pakistan's military intelligence agency were providing money and 
equipment to Taliban commanders fighting against the United States 
and allies in Afghanistan. The fourth paragraph said the article was 
based on interviews with a half-dozen American, Pakistani and other 
security officials who "requested anonymity because they were 
discussing classified and sensitive intelligence information."

Mark Mazzetti, who wrote the article with Eric Schmitt, explained the 
motivations of their sources. "Several people we talked to are 
clearly angry that there is this ongoing relationship between the spy 
service of an ally and an enemy of the United States," he said. The 
Pakistanis, on the other hand, wanted to explain their rationale for 
maintaining ties with the militants. Both sides had an agenda, 
Mazzetti said, but "if you talk to enough people, you can work your 
way to a version of the truth."

For Times readers, it was a valuable story about a part of the world 
where the administration faces decisions with life-and-death 
consequences.

*

A recent article reported that a Republican senator was accusing 
Obama of undercutting protections for government whistle-blowers. The 
White House response, including the unremarkable quotation that Obama 
was "committed to whistle-blower protections," came from an 
administration official who could not be identified by name or title.

Charlie Savage, the reporter, said a spokesman in the White House 
press office offered a brief response attributed to him by name. 
Instead, Savage accepted a background interview with an official who 
actually dealt with the policy but could not be identified by name. 
Savage said he argued that anonymity was not justified in this case, 
but the spokesman would not give, and "I decided with great 
reluctance to accept the deal."

The 25-minute interview, in which Savage wrested the concession that 
the official could be identified as a lawyer, produced useful 
information about the administration's thinking. Savage said he also 
learned more that will inform his reporting in the future, but he was 
still frustrated by the experience and protested to the press office 
the next day.

It was a reasonable judgment to accept the background interview, but 
the self-serving quotation went too far. The spokesman could have 
said as much - with a name behind it.

Incidentally, I talked to the spokesman, but he would not let me 
identify him. See how insidious this anonymity thing is?

*

Sheryl Gay Stolberg, who covers the White House, wrote last week 
about Obama as commander in chief. The article, as published, had no 
anonymous sources, but she said it originally had two.

One was a "senior foreign policy adviser" who, asked whether Obama 
considered himself a war president, said Obama did not feel he had 
the luxury of choosing what would define his presidency. Stolberg 
said she pressed, unsuccessfully, to get the quote on the record. Her 
editor said the quote should come out, and she agreed - a good 
decision. The second source was a defense official who described 
differences between how Obama and former President George W. Bush 
decided troop levels in Afghanistan and Iraq. The official would not 
be quoted on the record, so Stolberg found a public statement by 
Defense Secretary Robert Gates that made the point.

Dean Baquet, the Washington bureau chief, said he will consider 
leading an effort to persuade the Obama administration, while it is 
still new, to forswear bad habits in handling the press - like giving 
a roomful of reporters a background briefing by a top figure who 
cannot be revealed to the public. Pervasive anonymity enhances the 
credibility of neither the news media nor an administration that came 
to office promising transparency.

It would be wrong, however, to lay all of the blame with the sources. 
News organizations are sometimes too eager to pounce on misstatements 
and missteps, leaving those they cover understandably wary. Credibility 
runs both ways.

It may seem naïve to think that an entrenched culture in which both 
sides have used each other for decades can change, but a similar 
effort four years ago produced some temporary improvement in the Bush 
administration, which was much less committed to openness.

At his news conference last week, Obama said, "I'm a big believer in 
persistence." So am I.

The public editor can be reached by e-mail: [email protected].

Copyright 2009 The New York Times Company

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to