March 29, 2009

Wikipedia: Exploring Fact City
By NOAM COHEN
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/29/weekinreview/29cohen.html?pagewanted=print


Contributors to Wikipedia have wondered aloud lately if — perish the 
thought — they are running out of topics. The obvious articles, 
low-hanging fruit like “China,” “Moses” and “Homer Simpson,” have been 
written and rewritten hundreds of times. There are more than 2.8 million 
articles on the English version of Wikipedia alone. Already looking 
back, Wikipedia this month got its first serious memoir, “The Wikipedia 
Revolution,” by Andrew Lih, an early Wikipedian (yes, that is what they 
call themselves), who writes about how “a bunch of nobodies created the 
world’s greatest encyclopedia.”

But these concerns seem misplaced — Wikipedia can no more be completed 
than can New York City, which O. Henry predicted would be “a great place 
if they ever finish it.” In fact, with its millions of visitors and 
hundreds of thousands of volunteers, its ever-expanding total of 
articles and languages spoken, Wikipedia may be the closest thing to a 
metropolis yet seen online.

Like a city, Wikipedia is greater than the sum of its parts; for 
example, the random encounters there are often more compelling than the 
articles themselves. The search for information resembles a walk through 
an overbuilt quarter of an ancient capital. You circle around topics on 
a path that appears to be shifting. Ultimately the journey ends and you 
are not sure how you got there.

Wikipedia articles can send you down unlikely alleyways in two ways. 
First, there are links that direct you to the same article in another 
language, a trippy experience that sheds light on a culture. Spend time 
in German Wikipedia, and you find jazz musicians like Thelonious Monk 
with articles far longer than those written in their own language; you 
may also come upon odd areas of deep interest, like “pecherei,” the 
extraction of resin from trees — no English equivalent provided — and 15 
different tools needed for the job.

Second, at the bottom of most articles, there are the categories — 
impromptu neighborhoods, or perhaps civic organizations, that bind 
together the virtual encyclopedia. There are unsurprising ones, like 
“Jewish comedians,” found at the bottom of the Jerry Seinfeld article; 
and then there are the quirky kind, like this one I stumbled upon: 
“Literary devices playing with meaning.” It was in the latter category 
that I came upon the article “Mondegreen,” which describes the 
phenomenon of mishearing song lyrics, which led to “Soramimi,” a 
Japanese term for hearing lyrics in foreign languages as Japanese 
phrases, which led to the discovery that the heavy metal band Metallica 
has a line in “Enter Sandman” that frequently is heard by Japanese as 
“Let’s go to Chiyoda Life Insurance.” Which led to ...

It is a tale of spontaneous organization and achievement. Until 
recently, Wikipedia was able to operate on a budget of less than $3 
million a year. Today it is still only $7 million, all donations and 
grants. No advertising, no sugar daddy. A rags-to-rags story of world 
domination in information that could only have happened in the Internet age.

In “The City in History,” Lewis Mumford tried to explain how cities came 
to be: “In the earliest gathering about a grave or a painted symbol, a 
great stone or sacred grove, one has the beginning of a succession of 
civic institutions that range from the temple to the astronomical 
observatory, from the theater to the university.”

In its seven years of existence Wikipedia has become one of the top 10 
global Web sites. It has many fewer visitors than Google, yes, but it is 
in shouting distance of Amazon and eBay, with more than 60 million 
Americans visiting in January. Hundreds of thousands of people — some 
anonymous, some using pseudonyms, others exactly who they say they are — 
have thus far come together to collaborate.

A single article, say about the Mumbai attacks last year, can have more 
than 1,000 contributors. Their discussions on how best to write the 
article can occupy pages, all guided by one of Wikipedia’s founding 
principles: “Assume good faith.”

Wikipedia encourages contributors to mimic the basic civility, trust, 
cultural acceptance and self-organizing qualities familiar to any city 
dweller. Why don’t people attack each other on the way home? Why do they 
stay in line at the bank? Why don’t people guffaw at the person with 
blue hair?

The police may be an obvious answer. But this misses the compact among 
city dwellers. Since their creation, cities have had to be accepting of 
strangers — no judgments — and residents learn to be subtly 
accommodating, outward looking.

Mumford elaborates: “Even before the city is a place of fixed residence, 
it begins as a meeting place to which people periodically return: the 
magnet comes before the container, and this ability to attract 
nonresidents to it for intercourse and spiritual stimulus no less than 
trade remains one of the essential criteria of the city, a witness to 
its essential dynamism, as opposed to the more fixed and indrawn form of 
the village, hostile to the outsider.”

The marvel of Wikipedia — and cities — is that all the intercourse and 
spiritual stimulus don’t make living there impossible. Rather, they are 
exactly what makes living there possible.

Mr. Lih at one point enlists the urban reformer Jane Jacobs to back up 
this point. For him, urban stability is replicated through the 
transparency of wikis — every change ever made at Wikipedia (every 
discussion as well) is recorded. Ms. Jacobs, he writes, “argued that 
sidewalks provided three important things: safety, contact and the 
assimilation of children.” She may as well have been talking about 
wikis, he says: “A wiki has all its activities happening in the open for 
inspection, as on Jacobs’s sidewalk. Trust is built by observing the 
actions of others in the community and discovering people with like or 
complementary interests.”

It is this sidewalk-like transparency and collective responsibility that 
makes Wikipedia as accurate as it is. The greater the foot traffic, the 
safer the neighborhood. Thus, oddly enough, the more popular, even 
controversial, an article is, the more likely it is to be accurate and 
free of vandalism. It is the obscure articles — the dead-end streets and 
industrial districts, if you will — where more mayhem can be committed. 
It takes longer for errors or even malice to be noticed and rooted out. 
(Fewer readers will be exposed to those errors, too.)

Like the modern megalopolis, Wikipedia has decentralized growth. 
Wikipedia adds articles the way Beijing adds neighborhoods — whenever 
the mood strikes. It is open to all: the sixth-grader typing in material 
from her homework assignment, the graduate student with a limited grasp 
of English. No judgments, no entry pass.

One of Wikipedia’s governing principles is N.P.O.V. (neutral point of 
view), in much the same way Venice or Amsterdam or New York City in 
their heyday were uninterested in the religious, ethnic or political 
fights rampaging across the world. They, like Wikipedia, were polyglot 
homes for all who arrived on their shores.

But perhaps the most convincing argument for Wikipedia as an urban 
outpost on the Internet is the deep unease — even anger — it engenders. 
Alone among the miraculous and destructive creations of the Internet — 
Google, Facebook, Flickr, eBay — Wikipedia can cause the professional 
classes to seethe. Or run away fast, arms flailing.

People don’t treat ineffectual inventions as taboo — that is reserved 
for things like evolution, alcohol or, yes, cities. And just as the 
world has had plenty of creationists, temperance societies and 
ruralists, there is a professional class of Wikipedia skeptics. They, 
too, have some seriously depraved behavior to expose: Wikipedia 
represents a world without experts! A world without commercial news 
outlets! A world lacking in distinction between the trivial and the 
profound! A world overrun with facts but lacking in wisdom!

It’s all reminiscent of the longstanding accusations made against 
cities: They don’t produce anything! All they do is gossip! They think 
they are so superior! They wouldn’t last a week if we farmers stopped 
shipping our food! They don’t know the meaning of real work!

This argument represents a true clash of ideas. It is clear from Mr. 
Lih’s account that nearly every time Wikipedia has come to a fork in the 
road where the project could have chosen to impose more restrictions on 
who could edit what — even insist on a bit of expertise — it has chosen 
not to. That has made all the difference. The vindication of those 
choices — by Wikipedia and cities — is proved each time some yokel 
overcomes his fear and decides to make a visit and stay awhile.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to