March 30, 2009, 10:23 pm

Microsoft Encarta Dies After Long Battle With Wikipedia
By Noam Cohen
NY Times

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/03/30/microsoft-encarta-dies-after-long-battle-with-wikipedia/?pagemode=print


Microsoft delivered the coup de grâce Monday to its dying Encarta 
encyclopedia, acknowledging what everyone else realized long ago: it 
just couldn’t compete with Wikipedia, a free, collaborative project that 
has become the leading encyclopedia on the Web.

In January, Wikipedia got 97 percent of the visits that Web surfers in 
the United States made to online encyclopedias, according to the 
Internet ratings service Hitwise. Encarta was second, with 1.27 percent. 
Unlike Wikipedia, where volunteer editors quickly update popular 
entries, Encarta can be embarrassingly outdated. The entry for Joseph R. 
Biden Jr., for example, identifies him as vice president-elect and a 
U.S. senator.

The Encarta software will be removed from stores by June, Microsoft 
said, and the affiliated worldwide Web sites will be closed by the end 
of October. (The Japanese site will continue until the end of December.)

Without mentioning Wikipedia directly, Microsoft explained its decision 
on a FAQ page for Encarta. “The category of traditional encyclopedias 
and reference material has changed,” it said. “People today seek and 
consume information in considerably different ways than in years past. 
As part of Microsoft’s goal to deliver the most effective and engaging 
resources for today’s consumer, it has made the decision to exit the 
Encarta business.”

On that same page, the company asked itself if other Microsoft 
educational software would be discontinued as well. Its answer: “We’re 
not making any other announcements at this time.” The bulk of the 
Microsoft FAQ page explains how subscribers to the Encarta service could 
get a refund on what they had paid.

In the mid- to late 1980s, when Encarta began as a pet project of 
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates, it had the potential to be as 
unsettling to the traditional encyclopedia business as Wikipedia is today.

After being rebuffed by Encyclopedia Britannica as a partner in making 
material available to personal computer users as a CD-ROM, Microsoft in 
1989 went to Funk & Wagnalls and decided to make “a virtue of 
necessity,” according to 2006 case history by Professor Shane Greenstein 
and Michelle Devereux for the Kellogg School of Management at 
Northwestern University.

“Microsoft could not build its encyclopedia on the highest-quality 
content,” they wrote. “Instead, it invested in choice graphics and sound 
to bring value to its product.”

In the pre-Internet and early Internet era, Encarta was an example of 
Microsoft trying to enhance the experience of PC users –- a way of 
selling the computer experience to an unfamiliar public.

“You could very much argue that Encarta, was a me-too product, a way to 
add some more value to the Microsoft suite” of software that came with 
Windows, said Andrew Lih, author of “The Wikipedia Revolution,” a new 
history of Wikipedia. “Microsoft never added the resources or brainpower 
to be anything more than that.” (I wrote about Mr. Lih’s book and the 
significance of Wikipedia in Sunday’s Times.)

As the amount of information available online grew exponentially, it 
became quaint to purchase DVDs of factual material. While a free, 
text-oriented project like Wikipedia could not compete with the graphics 
and design of Encarta, that wasn’t important to consumers.

Still, Mr. Lih said something would be lost in the shuttering of 
Encarta. “Bill Gates bought Corbis, and Encarta had access to all these 
images that Wikipedia could never get,” he said. “Right now, that is a 
big weakness of Wikipedia -– the material has to be free.”

Mathias Schindler, one of the administrators of German Wikipedia, said 
he had already sent an e-mail to Microsoft asking the company to release 
the material from Encarta that it doesn’t plan to use anymore.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to