May 10, 2009

A Pocket-Size Leveler in an Outsize Land
By ANAND GIRIDHARADAS
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/10/weekinreview/10giridharadas.html?_r=1&ref=technology&pagewanted=print


VERLA, India — Sometimes a technology comes along and crystallizes a 
cultural moment. Not since Americans and their automobiles in the 1950s, 
perhaps, have a people and a technology wedded as happily as Indians and 
their cellphones — small and big, vibrating and tringing, BlackBerry and 
plain vanilla.

And neither India nor the cellphone will be the same after the pairing. 
India now adds more cellphone connections than anyplace else, with 15.6 
million in March alone. The cost of calling is among the lowest in the 
world. And the device plays a larger-than-life role here — more so, it 
seems, than in the wealthy countries where it was invented.

Of course, in so vast a country, India’s nearly 400 million cellphone 
users still account for only a third of the population. But the 
technology has seeped down the social strata, into slums and small towns 
and villages, becoming that rare Indian possession to traverse the walls 
of caste and region and class; a majority of subscribers are now outside 
the major cities and wealthiest states. And while the average bill, of 
less than $5 per month, represents 7 percent of the average Indian’s 
income, enough Indians apparently consider the sacrifice worth it: if 
present trends continue, in five years every Indian will have a cellphone.

What makes the cellphone special in India? It is partly that India 
skipped the land-line revolution, making cellphones the first real 
contact with the outside world for hundreds of millions of people. It is 
partly that, with few other machines selling so briskly, the cellphone 
in India is forced variously to be a personal computer, flashlight, 
camera, stereo, video-game console and day organizer as well. It is 
partly that India’s relative poverty compels providers to be more 
creative to survive.

But it is also that the cellphone appeals deeply to the Indian 
psychology, to the spreading desire for personal space and voice, not in 
defiance of the family and tribe, but in the chaotic midst of it.

Imagine what it was like — in the Pre-Cellular Age — to be young in a 
traditional household. People are everywhere. Doors are open. Judgments 
fly. Bedrooms are shared. What phones exist are centrally located.

The cellphone serves, then, as a technology of individuation. On the 
cellphone, you are your own person. No one answers your calls or reads 
your messages. Your number is just yours.

And yet the young Indian rebel, unlike his Western counterpart, does not 
rebel totally. He wants to savor his new individuality, but do so while 
sitting with his parents having dinner, listening to his grandmother 
implore him to get married. He listens, then taps a few keys on his 
cellphone to escape, then listens some more, and taps, and listens.

The cellphone appeals, too, because it plays into the Indian need to 
place people. Cellular differences today perform the role that forehead 
markings and strings around torsos and metal bracelets once did: 
announcing who outranks whom.

Small people have small phones, and big people have big ones. Small 
people have numerical-soup numbers, and big people have numbers that end 
in 77777 or something equally important-sounding or easy to remember. 
Small people have one phone, and big people have two. Small people set 
their phones merely to ring, and big people make Bollywood songs play 
when you call them.

The cellphone, in short, has made itself Indian. There are 65 times more 
cellphone connections than broadband Internet links, and the gap is 
widening. And so those who wish to influence Indians are not waiting for 
the computer to catch on, but are seeking ways to adapt the cellphone to 
the things Westerners do online.

Indian companies have invented methods, via simple cellphone 
text-messaging, to wire money to temples, pay for groceries, find jobs 
and send and receive e-mail messages (on humble phones with no data 
connection).

But the most intriguing notion is that cellphones could transform Indian 
democracy.

Even in this voting season — the results of a four-week election will be 
announced May 16 — Indians are famously cynical about their 
senior-citizen-dominated, dynastic, corrupt politics. The educated often 
sit out elections. But with cellphones becoming near universal, 
experiments are sprouting with the goal of forging a new bond between 
citizen and state, through real-time, 24-hour cellular participation.

In the southern state of Andhra Pradesh, citizens who file a 
right-to-information request can now check its status via text message. 
Anyone who has been to an Indian government office, begging men in 
safari suits to do their job, will welcome this service.

A number of civic groups, meanwhile, have devised cellphone-based ways 
of informing voters about candidates for Parliament. If you text your 
postal code to the Association for Democratic Reforms, it will reply 
with candidate profiles like this:

CANDIDATE A Crim. Cases - No, Assets 175373142, Liab 0, Edu 
graduate_professional

CANDIDATE B Crim. Cases - Yes (1), Assets 445015617, Liab 2489959, Edu 
illiterate

A new interactivity is dawning in the news media, too. Now, via 
cellphone, citizens are talking back to the press, creating a continuous 
feedback loop between reporters and the public opinion they shape. 
Channels solicit text messages during broadcasts to air opinions and to 
poll viewers. Comments crawl across the screen as the talking heads talk.

In 2006, a court acquitted Manu Sharma, a politician’s son, of the 
murder of a model, Jessica Lall, even though several witnesses testified 
that they had seen him shoot her. This was nothing new in India. But a 
groundswell of text-message anger made its way onto television screens 
and compelled officials to retry Mr. Sharma. He was eventually convicted 
and given a life sentence.

Imagine the future: a young woman sits on her sofa. With a few taps, she 
checks that her tax return has been cleared. With a few more, she learns 
that her local legislator is a criminal, and she switches to the other 
candidate. She wires a campaign contribution by text. And then she 
notices on television a debate on her favorite topic, and listens to the 
arguments and taps hurriedly into her phone words that will soon scroll 
across the screen.

It is not Athens, but it would be a start: in the world’s largest 
democracy, government not by passive consent, but by something like a 
conversation.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to