May 8, 2009, 9:48 am

Will the Phone Industry Need a Bailout, Too?

By Saul Hansell
NY Times

http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/08/will-the-phone-industry-need-a-bailout-too/


Congress has asked the Federal Communication Commission to develop a 
national policy for broadband deployment. But it might be more important 
to think through how the country will handle the aging and increasingly 
less relevant copper phone network.

You can see the problem building every quarter, when the phone companies 
report they serve ever fewer landlines. They are mainly losing customers 
to cable companies, which offer competing broadband and voice services 
that make copper phone lines unnecessary. More people are also deciding 
to abandon landlines for cellphones.

AT&T lost 12 percent of its landlines over the last year. Verizon, which 
is converting some customers to fiber, lost 10 percent. The story is 
similar at smaller phone companies like Qwest, Embarq, Fairpoint and 
Frontier, but these companies don’t have the wireless business to help 
bail them out.

As all these companies lose wireline revenue, the costs of maintaining 
the wires strung on poles and dug through trenches is not falling nearly 
as quickly. It now costs an average of $52 a year to maintain a copper 
phone line, up from $43 in 2003, largely because of the declining number 
of lines, according to Larry Vanston, president of research firm 
Technology Futures, as quoted on GigaOm. There are more reports, such as 
this one about Verizon, that the telcos are skimping on maintenance of 
their copper wires.

I am also having a hard time seeing how the pricing structure of the 
voice business can hold up. Right now, voice traffic is such a tiny 
piece of the overall data moved over the Internet that the cost is 
insignificant. One clue can be found in the most recent financial 
statement of Vonage, the Internet phone company, which show that its 
direct costs of providing telephone service come to $6.67 a month for 
each subscriber. And the largest part of that amount is not true cost, 
but subsidies to rural phone carriers by way of an inscrutably complex 
system that governs how companies pay each other when connecting 
long-distance calls.

To be sure, the costs to run and maintain wires to people’s homes (for 
any combination of phone, Internet and television) is a great deal 
higher than $6.67 a month. But for the vast majority of people who buy 
Internet and TV service already, the extra they pay for phone service is 
entirely unconnected to the actual costs of providing it.

So far, stand-alone voice-over-Internet services have not really caught 
on with consumers. Vonage actually lost customers in the first quarter, 
when you might have imagined the tough economy would drive people to its 
cheaper service. And that’s after spending more money on marketing than 
it does on providing its phone service.

But as a policy maker — or an investor, for that matter — these 
economics make for a great deal of risk. If competition ever creates a 
significant shift to Internet-based phone service, it could quickly 
decimate the already precarious economics of the local phone business.

You can see these stresses already in the local phone companies with 
heavy debt burdens from leveraged buyouts. Hawaiian Telecom filed for 
bankruptcy protection in December, three years after it was bought from 
Verizon for $1.6 billion by the Carlyle Group. Facing stiff competition 
from Time Warner Cable, the company has lost more than 20 percent of its 
landlines. The debt of Fairpoint Communications, which bought the New 
England operations of Verizon, was recently downgraded by Moody’s to B3; 
the ratings firm cited increasing risk that Fairpoint would default on 
its debt.

Craig Moffett, a telecommunications analyst at Sanford C. Bernstein & 
Company, suggests that even the phone companies that don’t have such 
high debt burdens are heading down the same path.

“These are fundamentally bankruptcy stories,” Mr. Moffett said, 
suggesting the government may well be forced to confront a very 
expensive bailout of the telephone industry in a few years. “They have 
employment that is on a par with the big three automakers. And their 
pension obligations are close to being on par with the automakers too.”

All of these trends, of course, have been visible for years. But 
sometimes it is the slow-moving problems — like, say, rising subprime 
home lending — that are the hardest for government to deal with before 
there is a crisis.

What good will it do for the F.C.C. to come up with a spiffy new plan to 
get faster cheaper broadband to more people if the phone companies fail 
and millions of people won’t be able to dial 911 in an emergency?

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to