July 16, 2009, 11:04 AM ET

Franken Out-Wonks New Colleagues on Net-Neutrality Question

By Amy Schatz
Wall Street Journal

http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2009/07/16/franken-out-wonks-new-colleagues-on-net-neutrality-question-for-sotomayor/?mod=rss_WSJBlog?mod=


The junior Senator from Minnesota, Al Franken, asked a decidedly unfunny 
question Wednesday afternoon when it was his turn to quiz Supreme Court 
nominee Sonya Sotomayor.

Franken turned to the contentious issue of net neutrality, or rules that 
would require cable and phone companies to treat legal Internet traffic 
equally and would prevent the creation of a two-tiered system that would 
allow speedier deliver of premium services.

Public interest groups have pressed Congress to pass explicit rules 
requiring net neutrality since it’s not entirely clear the FCC has 
authority to prevent Internet providers from blocking or delaying some 
Internet traffic. A federal appeals court is currently considering that 
issue now in a dispute between the FCC and Comcast, which argues the FCC 
doesn’t have explicit authority to enforce net-neutrality rules.

Earlier this week, University of Nebraska-Lincoln law professor Marvin 
Ammori published an article in the Huffington Post about connections 
between Internet rules and the First Amendment, and made some of the 
same points Franken brought up in the hearing.

The Internet “plays an essential role in our democracy by allowing 
anyone with a computer connected to the Internet to publish their ideas, 
their thoughts, their opinions and reach a world-wide audience of 
hundreds of millions of people in seconds. This is free speech,” Franken 
said, before asking about a 2005 Supreme Court decision about 
deregulation of Internet lines.

In the summer of 2005, the Supreme Court, in a 6-3 decision, essentially 
said the FCC has authority to decide how to regulate Internet services.

The case involved a small California Internet provider, Brand X 
Internet, which challenged a 2002 FCC decision that said cable companies 
weren’t required to share their lines with other companies. The agency 
essentially changed the classification of those Internet lines so many 
rules wouldn’t apply anymore.

Internet activists have complained that was a bad idea, because 
deregulating those lines meant that cable and phone companies had wide 
latitude for deciding how they’d deliver Internet traffic (or not 
deliver it at all).

That Supreme Court decision, Franken said, opened up a lot of concerns 
about net neutrality, and he asked Sotomayor if the American public 
“have a compelling First Amendment interest in ensuring…that the 
Internet stays open and accessible.”

“Brand X was a question of which government agency would regulate those 
(Internet) providers,” Sotomayor replied. “The role of the court is 
never to make the policy, it’s to wait until Congress acts.”

She tried to soften those remarks a bit, by talking about how the 
Internet affects many parts of society, including property rights and 
freedom of speech. “The children in my life virtually live on it now,” 
she said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to