Concerns raised as LA looks to Google Web services

Jul 17, 2009  2:29 PM (ET)

By MICHAEL R. BLOOD
Associated Press

http://apnews.myway.com//article/20090717/D99GC5U82.html


LOS ANGELES (AP) - Security and privacy concerns have been raised over a 
multimillion-dollar proposal by Los Angeles to tap Google Inc.'s 
Internet-based services for government e-mail, police records and other 
confidential data.

At issue is the security of computerized records on everything from 
police investigations to potholes as the nation's second-largest city 
considers dumping its in-house computer network for Google e-mail and 
office programs that are accessed over the Internet.

Paul Weber, president of the Los Angeles Police Protective League, 
complained Thursday that the union had scant information on the plan or 
what it would mean for the safety of sensitive records, such as 
narcotics or gang investigations.

His worries came just one day after the online-messaging service Twitter 
acknowledged hackers were able to access confidential information stored 
with Google, which has been promoting greater use of "cloud computing" - 
storing data online rather than on individual computers under a 
company's or government agency's direct control.

The shift toward doing more over the Web could make it much easier for 
hackers to gain access to corporate or government files. No longer would 
someone need to try to break through layers of security firewalls. As 
various personal and work accounts become increasingly linked together, 
all one needs is a single password to access documents just like a 
regular employee.

In the Twitter case, a hacker got the password for an employee's 
personal e-mail account - possibly by guessing, or by correctly 
answering a security question - and worked from there to steal 
confidential company documents.

Weber said the Los Angeles proposal could increase the exposure to 
computer hacking.

"Any time you go to a Web-based system, that puts you just a little 
further out than you were before," he said. "Drug cartels would pay any 
sum of money to be aware of our progress on investigations."

City Councilman Tony Cardenas, who heads a committee that will discuss 
the proposed contract next week, said he has a "laundry list of 
questions that need to be answered."

"While legitimate concerns have been raised by LAPD (Police Department) 
and the City Attorney's Office because of the nature of their work, we 
must find a solution that meets everyone's needs," Cardenas said in a 
statement. "We can't say we are a first-class city and keep the same 
antiquated communication systems."

City officials are negotiating a potential $7.2 million deal with 
contractor Computer Sciences Corp. to replace the city's computer system.

An analysis by the city administrative officer notes that Los Angeles' 
e-mail and office programs are now owned and operated by the city. Under 
the proposed plan, government e-mail, documents and data would be 
accessed over the Internet "and housed at Google's facilities," 
according to the analysis.

Computer Sciences representatives did not immediately return e-mail 
messages Thursday and Friday.

If approved, Los Angeles would be the second major city after 
Washington, D.C., to use Google's Internet-based services, known as 
Google Apps. The company has been promoting the package to other 
government agencies, too, as a way to cut costs and ensure access to 
Google-developed technical innovations.

Google said in a statement that more than 1.75 million businesses use 
the technology. An unknown number of them pay the Mountain View-based 
company $50 per user per year for a premium version designed for 
businesses, government agencies and other robust needs.

In a statement, Google said its services, which can store information at 
a number of Google-run data centers around the world, are "extremely 
reliable, safe and secure."

It's not yet clear how existing federal and state privacy laws apply to 
data sent to computers outside a government agency's direct control.

Pam Dixon, executive director of the nonprofit research group World 
Privacy Forum, said in a letter to Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa Thursday 
that Los Angeles "rushed into this without enough careful consideration 
of all of the consequences, and without enough attention to the details 
of protecting the privacy of the data."

"The transfer of so many city records ... may threaten the privacy 
rights of city residents, undermine the security of other sensitive 
information, violate both state and federal laws, and potentially damage 
vital city legal and other interests," Dixon wrote.

Matt Szabo, a spokesman for the mayor, said the privacy and security of 
sensitive information "will be of paramount concern as the city moves 
forward to upgrade its inefficient, 20th century network. Upgrading our 
system will save money and allow for more rapid and efficient service to 
L.A. residents."

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to