Air Force Plans for All-Drone Future

By David Axe
Wired News

July 17, 2009 | 11:37 am

http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2009/07/air-force-plans-for-all-drone-future/


Is the day of the hot-shot fighter jock nearly done?

An Air Force study, released without much fanfare on Wednesday, suggests 
that tomorrow’s dogfighers might not have pilots in the cockpit. The 
Unmanned Aircraft System Flight Plan. which sketches out possible drone 
development through the year 2047, comes with plenty of qualifiers. But 
it envisions a radical future. In an acronym-dense 82 pages, the Air 
Force explains how ever-larger and more sophisticated flying robots 
could eventually replace every type of manned aircraft in its inventory 
— everything from speedy, air-to-air fighters to lumbering bombers and 
tankers.

Emphasis on “might” and “could.” While revealing how robots can equal 
the capabilities of traditional planes, the Air Force is careful to 
emphasize that an all-bot air fleet is not inevitable. Rather, drones 
will represent “alternatives” to manned planes, in pretty much every 
mission category.

Some of the missions tapped for possible, future drones are currently 
considered sacrosanct for human pilots. Namely: dogfighting and nuclear 
bombing. Drones “are unlikely to replace the manned aircraft for air 
combat missions in the policy-relevant future,” Manjeet Singh Pardesi 
wrote in Air & Space Power Journal, just four years ago. Dogfighting was 
considered too fluid, too fast, for a drone’s narrow “situational 
awareness.” As for nuclear bombing: “Many aviators, in particular, 
believe that a ‘man in the loop’ should remain an integral part of the 
nuclear mission because of the psychological perception that there is a 
higher degree of accountability and moral certainty with a manned 
bomber,” Adam Lowther explained in Armed Forces Journal, in June.

Despite this, the Air Force identifies a future “MQ-Mc” Unmanned Aerial 
System for dogfighting, sometime after 2020. The MQ-Mc will also handle 
“strategic attack,” a.k.a nuke bombing. Less controversial is the 
conjectural MQ-L, a huge drone that could fill in for today’s tankers 
and transports.

But just because a drone could replace a manned plane, doesn’t 
necessarily mean it definitely will. “We do not envision replacing all 
Air Force aircraft with UAS,” Col. Eric Mathewson told Danger Room by 
email. “We do plan on considering UAS as alternatives to traditionally 
manned aircraft across a broad spectrum of Air Force missions … but 
certainly not all.” In other words, in coming years drones might be able 
to do everything today’s manned planes can do — technically speaking. 
But the Air Force still might find good reasons — moral, financial or 
otherwise — to keep people in some cockpits.

The Flight Plan represents a new twist in a heated debate raging in 
Congress over the Pentagon’s 3,000-strong fighter force. The legislature 
is split over whether to fund more F-22 fighters — a move that could 
draw a veto from President Barack Obama. Secretary of Defense Robert 
Gates has long favored drone development over buying more manned 
fighters, and in May Joint Chiefs chair Admiral Mike Mullen predicted 
Gates’ position would win out, over the long term. “There are those that 
see [the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter] as the last manned fighter,” Mullen 
said. “I’m one that’s inclined to believe that.” General Atomics, which 
makes the popular Predator line of drones, underscored Mullen’s comment 
by unveiling its new, faster Predator C.

If Flight Plan proves an accurate predictor, it’s not just manned 
fighters (maybe) headed for extinction, but (maybe) nuclear bombers, 
transports, tankers … nearly all human-occupied military planes.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to