http://www.latimes.com/news/local/crime/la-me-public-records17-2009jul17,0,4147298.story

L.A. weighs plan to replace computer software with Google service
If OKd by the City Council, the plan would shift protection of internal 
data and public records from the city to the Internet giant. The LAPD 
has raised concerns about shielding arrest information.

By David Zahniser and Phil Willon
Los Angeles Times

July 17, 2009



Frustrated by a slow and antiquated computer system, the city of Los 
Angeles is weighing a plan to replace its e-mail and records retention 
software with a service provided by Google, a move that could allow the 
Internet giant to retain sensitive records transmitted by the police and 
other municipal agencies.

If approved by the City Council, responsibility for protecting the 
internal data and public records would be shifted from the city to 
Google, according to a report submitted this week to a council committee 
that will weigh the proposed $7.25-million contract.

Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa favors the effort to modernize the e-mail 
system, which his spokesman, Matt Szabo, described as "Pac-Man-era 
technology."

The current system "has got to be the slowest, most inefficient, 
crash-prone e-mail system in the history of mankind," Szabo added.

Los Angeles Police Department spokesman Lt. John Romero said it would be 
inappropriate for his agency to comment while a contract is being 
negotiated. But acting City Administrative Officer Ray Ciranna, the 
city's top financial advisor, said the LAPD has raised questions about 
Google's ability to shield sensitive arrest information.

"Of all the city agencies, they certainly have been the one that's the 
most concerned," Ciranna said. "They don't want any information that, 
for any reason, gets un-encrypted and you have sensitive information 
being leaked out."

Washington, D.C., is the only major city using Google e-mail and office 
applications, but others are contemplating a switch, according to a 
Google official. The applications and data would be housed on Google 
servers, not on city property, and accessible via presumably secure 
Internet connections.

'Cloud computing'

That system, known as "cloud computing," would eliminate the need for 
the city to store programs or information on individual in-house 
computers. "Government agencies at all levels -- federal, state and city 
-- are looking to cloud computing as a way to advance innovation while 
decreasing costs," Google spokeswoman Aviva Gilbert said.

The contract, which could cover a maximum of five years, would need 
approval from the full council and Villaraigosa's signature. A 
high-level official with the city's Information Technology Agency, which 
has handled the bidding process, said he expects the LAPD to join the 
Google e-mail system once it receives assurance from the state's 
Department of Justice that arrest records will be protected.

"Until they get the full approval, they can't join the e-mail system," 
said Kevin Crawford, assistant general manager of the technology agency.

The contract will come up for review Tuesday before the council's 
three-member Information Technology and General Services Committee.

Gilbert, the Google spokeswoman, said cloud computing has proved to be 
reliable and secure, with Motorola, Genentech and other companies 
adopting it.

Still, questions about such applications were raised by the media 
earlier this week after Twitter Inc.'s cloud-based computer system was 
broken into and confidential documents were copied. The hacker appears 
to have guessed the password for an employee's personal e-mail account 
and worked from there to steal confidential company documents.

Internally, city officials also have asked whether Google, as keeper of 
the records, would be forced to respond to public information requests. 
"Release of this data by Google without appropriate review by the city 
attorney could compromise the city's position regarding pending or 
potential litigation," the report states.

City officials hope to have the Google system installed before Dec. 31. 
If the council misses that deadline, the city could be required to pay 
for continuing maintenance on the current GroupWise e-mail system. City 
workers have complained that the existing system crashes frequently and 
lacks sufficient memory, among other things.

Peter Scheer, director of the California First Amendment Coalition, said 
the switch to Google also could improve access to public information, 
especially by attorneys or reporters.

Google has "remarkably sophisticated" search capabilities and provides a 
huge amount of database storage at minimal cost, Scheer said. "If you're 
asking for information, it's more likely you'll get a more complete and 
accurate response to your request, sooner rather than later."

Paul Weber, president of the Los Angeles Police Protective League, which 
represents the city's police officers, said the LAPD has not discussed 
the proposed contract with his union and cautioned it to move in a 
"deliberate manner."

'Serious breach'

Last month, the league accused the LAPD of a "serious breach of privacy" 
involving officers in the 77th Street Division's Gang Enforcement Unit. 
Officers in that unit who were being audited found that their names and 
serial numbers had been sent to recipients of the Police Commission's 
meeting agenda, according to a letter to officers.

"If the department were to have their information compromised, it would 
seriously impact the public's confidence in our department and impact 
our ability to police the city," Weber said.

Scheer said it's in Google's own financial interest to ensure that data 
remain secure. If the company's systems suffer any sort of breach, they 
could potentially lose billions of dollars of business. "The bigger 
Google is, the more careful they are going to be about protection of 
rights and privacy and rights of access," he said.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to