Tiny TV could make billions for FCC

It's a seasonal miracle

By Bill Ray
TheRegister.co.uk

24th December 2009 11:10 GMT

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/12/24/ctia_ces_spectrum_plan/


The Cellular Telephone Industries Association (CTIA) and Consumer 
Electronics Association (CES) co-authored the paper (pdf) which proposes 
replacing centralised TV transmitters with a network of small, low power 
stations which would work with existing set-top boxes and free up 
between 100 and 180MHz of spectrum - spectrum which the CTIA's members 
would love to get their hands on.

Proposals from the CTIA often verge on the hysterical - such as 
predicting the downfall of American industry if more radio spectrum 
isn't allocated post haste. Even this one can't help pointing out that 
only ten per cent of Americans rely (exclusively) on broadcast TV. But 
after the usual rant, the document sets out a surprisingly reasonable 
plan for shrinking TV spectrum usage, though a few technical barriers do 
remain.

Broadcast TV is based around huge transmitters, normally atop massive 
towers, which pump out enormous signals that can be picked up 40 miles 
away. Frequencies can be reused, but only for transmitters at least 80 
miles apart - actually much further due to variability in signal 
propagation. So in the USA there are around 1800 towers, which blanket 
the country with between 15 and 20 6MHz-wide channels (to carry one 
analogue channel or a digital multiplex) despite the fact that there are 
49 slots available.

That disparity is down to the "near-far problem", whereby the strength 
of signal necessary to reach 40 miles or more, causes the channel to 
leak into neighbouring channels for users sitting beside the 
transmitter. That reduces the channels which can be used, and the CTIA 
reckons it's using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

The new plan has lots of little transmitters, working on the same 
frequency to provide the same coverage and with synchronised 
transmissions. The significant problem here is "ghosting", whereby the 
TV receives the same signal twice with a tiny time delay between the two 
based on differing distances to the transmitters. Analogue TV has always 
had this problem, which literally results in a ghost image appearing 
slightly offset from the desired picture. But this is generally down to 
reflected signals bouncing off walls and suchlike, rather than picking 
up two signals at the same time.

The CTIA argues that modern set-top boxes are so armoured against 
receiving bounced ghost signals that they can cope with one coming from 
a different transmitter. Modern boxes accept the strongest signal and 
are capable of disregarding the others.

That assertion is the weak point, but if the CTIA has its sums right 
then there's little reason why the system wouldn't work. The group 
reckons it will cost less than $2bn to built the new transmitter network 
(based on 15-20 new transmitters for each one currently operating), 
while it estimates the value of the frequencies released at between 
$36bn and $65bn. We'd lean towards the lower estimate, but even if it's 
half that the plan makes economic sense.

Not that access to more spectrum is the only advantage CTIA members 
would see from the plan. All those new transmitters will need homes, and 
could easily be bolted onto cellular towers - reducing costs if not 
providing revenue for the operator. Let's also not forget that that plan 
would substantially reduce the available White Space which can be used 
without paying network operators a penny - so it's good news all round.

The technical issues around ghosting need examination, but this proposal 
certainly merits more attention and not just in America - the same model 
could equally well apply in the rest of the world too.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to