Google races to speed up the Web

By Juan Carlos Perez
InfoWorld

2009-12-22 04:30AM

http://www.infoworld.com/d/networking/google-races-speed-web-178


Google [1] is in a really big hurry to make the Web experience faster.

That became abundantly clear in 2009, when the company unveiled a steady 
stream of projects, products, and enhancements focused on increasing 
Internet speed.

The initiatives varied widely in scope and focus. They included 
optimization tools for webmasters to improve Web site performance. 
Others were speed-focused products like the Go programming language and 
Chrome OS [4]. Google also pushed proposals to revamp aging Internet 
protocols and lobbied governments for broadband improvements.

The common denominator across the various heterogeneous efforts is an 
urgent desire to speed up the Web. This is rooted in Google's deeply 
held belief that a faster Internet is good for everyone, drives up 
online usage all around, and boosts the company's business.

"The benefit of speed improvements is very substantial for the overall 
Internet. In the end, as the Internet gets faster, we benefit because 
people will use it more, which hopefully means they'll do more searches, 
which gets us more revenue," said Urs Hölzle, a Google fellow and senior 
vice president of operations.

At first pass, it's hard to argue with this reasoning, particularly when 
many of the Google efforts are free and available as open-source 
software, which anyone can adopt, modify and use.

Plus, Web latency remains a chronic, thorny problem with many 
improvement opportunities, and Google has the financial and talent 
resources needed to lead the way and tackle the bottlenecks.

"Google can afford to develop these projects in a way that's going to be 
strategic," said Sheri McLeish, a Forrester Research analyst. "Google 
has a luxury most companies don't. They're running a very successful 
business and what we're seeing is what that success affords them."

Still, as Google advances aggressively with its speed initiatives, it 
also indirectly increases its already considerable power and influence 
over people's and organization's Web activities, raising so-called 
"Goog-zilla" concerns.

For example, in early December, as part of this overall speed 
initiative, Google launched a new system to resolve DNS (domain name 
system) queries [5]. It said its product improves on existing DNS 
resolver technology with faster, more efficient caching and additional 
security safeguards.

The thing is, those who switch to Google Public DNS will let the company 
know which Web sites they're visiting. This adds to the already massive 
amount of user data Google has access to via its search engine, online 
services, and applications.

"Google definitely sees itself as being in a position to influence the 
future direction of the Web. From a business strategy perspective, it's 
smart of them, because clearly they're a major beneficiary of Web 
traffic," said Hadley Reynolds, an IDC analyst.

"However, many people are very concerned that when you add up this whole 
picture there can be some deep nefarious purpose behind all of these 
moves. That's a legitimate concern," Reynolds added.

Reynolds notes similarities between Google's rise to power on the Web 
using its leadership in search and the way in which Microsoft used its 
dominance of the PC OS to expand into many other areas of consumer and 
enterprise computing.

"When you add up all the elements, it amounts to essentially being a 
Windows kind of dominant player in the Web environment, creating the 
same kind of presence Microsoft has had on the PC and then the 
enterprise. Google clearly has a level of ambition to do the same kind 
of thing on the Web," Reynolds said.

"At this stage, no one in the Web environment has a similar platform 
from which to compete against Google," he added.

Hölzle said Google understands privacy concerns around its various 
products and initiatives, which is why the company strives to be clear 
and transparent in its policies related to user data collection, 
analysis and retention. After all, the company reasons, if people 
distrust Google, they will stop using its products and services.

For example, Google pledged that Google Public DNS will retain 
end-users' IP addresses for no longer than 48 hours, and that it will 
store for no longer than two weeks general data about the users' ISP and 
city. Google also promised not to use Google Public DNS traffic data to 
complement data it collects from users in its other services.

Nonetheless, as skeptics often point out, one must take Google at its 
word on faith, hoping it sticks to its promise not only now but also in 
the future, and that accidental data leaks or compromises don't occur.

Another concern is what some view as Google's sometimes short attention 
span, which causes the company to release early prototypes of often 
promising services that it later loses interest in and abandons. By 
Hölzle's estimation, Google has about 25 speed-focused projects in 
various degrees of completion.

"One of the bigger challenges for Google is delivering on its promises. 
It tends to make announcements very early in the development cycle to 
get people excited and interested, but then it seems to take a long time 
to move those products to production ready," McLeish said.

Hölzle said Google views its speed efforts as key [6] to its business, 
and that its commitment to them is solid and long term, supported by the 
company's top executives. Google even has a virtual team focused on 
speed matters with members in a wide variety of product groups.

Hölzle also pointed out that Google's speed obsession isn't a fad that 
caught on this year. The company has been stressing the importance of 
speed for several years, and many efforts unveiled in 2009 had been in 
the works since 2008 and before.

One ambitious speed initiative is SPDY [7], pronounced "speedy," which 
aims to revamp the venerable HTTP protocol for Web content transport. 
SPDY, still in experimental phase, could be much faster and better able 
to take advantage of broadband, a sort of "HTTP 3.0," Hölzle said.

In this area of legacy Internet protocols, Google backs HTML 5.0, 
because the company believes its improvements greatly help to narrow the 
performance gap between Web applications and PC applications.

Changes at the Internet protocol and standards level require 
industry-wide goodwill, consensus and collaboration, which are sometimes 
tricky to generate due to competitive tensions among vendors. Hölzle 
trusts Google will succeed with its proposals, especially SPDY, for 
which it has high expectations.

"The Internet community is good about having technical arguments and 
making them based on technology merits. If we show why [our proposals 
are] good and we can give people an open-source implementation to 
demonstrate how it works and also measurements to see what the benefit 
is, I'm confident we can change standards because everyone will realize 
it's for everyone's benefit," he said.

Another major area of focus for Google Web site design, where best 
practices are often ignored, even by major Web publishers, resulting on 
clunky and slow Web pages. Google has promoted good design principles 
and released webmaster tools like Page Speed [8]. This open-source 
Firefox add-on analyzes a site's server and front-end design and, based 
on a set of best practices, generates recommendations.

Then there are the products created primarily because Google saw an 
opportunity to build a better mousetrap, like the Chrome browser, 
launched last year, and Chrome OS and Go programming language, both 
introduced this year. Likewise, many improvements across its product 
line are driven by speed considerations. "We see again and again that if 
you make something faster, the usage goes up almost immediately," he said.

It remains to be seen if, in fact, what makes Google better and faster 
does indeed have similarly beneficial effects on the Internet community 
at large. With the velocity at which Google is pushing ahead its speed 
efforts, we'll likely find out soon enough.


Source URL (retrieved on 2009-12-24 09:15PM): 
http://www.infoworld.com/d/networking/google-races-speed-web-178


Links:
[1] http://www.infoworld.com/t/google
[2] 
http://www.infoworld.com/newsletters/subscribe?showlist=infoworld_network&source=fssr
[3] http://www.infoworld.com/../../../../test-center/%3Fsource%3Dfssr
[4] http://www.infoworld.com/t/Google Chrome OS
[5] 
http://www.infoworld.com/t/dns/google-launches-alternative-dns-resolver-918
[6] http://code.google.com/speed/
[7] http://www.chromium.org/spdy
[8] http://code.google.com/speed/page-speed/

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to