December 25, 2009

New Film Ignites Debate on Ratings Policy
By BROOKS BARNES
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/25/business/media/25ratings.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


LOS ANGELES — The romantic comedy “It’s Complicated” arrived at the 
multiplex on Friday complete with an R rating, ranking it in the same 
category as “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre” and “Basic Instinct” in the 
eyes of the Motion Picture Association of America.

But there is no violence in “It’s Complicated,” and the bedroom scenes 
are decidedly tame by contemporary standards. Instead, the R rating — 
which experts say could limit the box-office potential of the Universal 
Pictures film — comes largely from a sequence in which Steve Martin and 
Meryl Streep smoke marijuana.

Giggles ensue.

The rating has kicked up dust in Hollywood, with movie bloggers starting 
blistering attacks on the M.P.A.A. for being out of touch. The marijuana 
lobby is equally miffed. “This is an absurd ruling rooted in old 
cultural thinking,” said Allen St. Pierre, executive director of the 
National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws. Universal and 
Mr. Martin unsuccessfully appealed, seeking a PG-13 rating.

Conservative groups, meanwhile, find themselves in the rare position of 
cheering the ratings system instead of condemning it. Dan Isett, 
director of public policy for the Parents Television Council, which also 
monitors movies, said “It’s Complicated” was a “rare instance” of the 
board getting a rating correct.

“The last I checked, smoking pot was still illegal, illicit behavior,” 
he said. “Too often material gets rated lower than it should be.”

Figuring prominently in the brouhaha are other depictions of marijuana 
in cinema, particularly the scene in the 1980 comedy “9 to 5” showing 
Dolly Parton, Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin getting high and raiding the 
refrigerator. Its rating was PG.

“This demonstrates a real hilarity and inconsistency, especially given 
how far the medical marijuana movement has come,” said Martin Kaplan, 
the director of the Norman Lear Center for the study of entertainment 
and society at the University of Southern California.

The rumpus comes amid informal discussion about tweaking the ratings 
formula, particularly where R is involved. The M.P.A.A., a trade 
organization financed by the major studios, has ruminated about dividing 
the R rating into new categories. Already, the industry refers 
informally to movies that are “soft R” or “hard R.”

Nancy Meyers, who directed the film, declined to comment, as did 
Universal and the film’s producers.

But financial forces are at work against any changes. If the difference 
between a PG-13 and an R rating can be tens of millions of dollars at 
the box office, the last thing studios want is to slice the pie thinner. 
“In general, the more child-friendly the rating is — even for movies 
that might not be aimed at teenagers — the more tickets you sell,” said 
S. Abraham Ravid, a business professor at Rutgers University who has 
published many studies on movie economics.

Joan Graves, the chairwoman of the film industry’s Classification and 
Rating Administration, declined to comment on “It’s Complicated,” citing 
internal policy barring the public discussion of a specific picture. But 
she dismissed criticism of her board members.

“They react the way that most people react,” she said. “America is not 
just two coasts.”

Some in the industry see something deeper at work, arguing that the 
trade organization is on its best behavior because it has a lame-duck 
leader in Dan Glickman (who is to step down as chief executive in 
September) and because Congressional elections will take place next 
year. The Federal Trade Commission harshly criticized the movie industry 
this month for inappropriately advertising movies with PG-13 and R 
ratings to children.

It was not specifically the actual drug use that got “It’s Complicated,” 
about a divorced woman who has an affair with her remarried ex-husband, 
into this pickle, according to people with knowledge of how the decision 
was reached. Instead, the ratings board was concerned about what the 
movie did not have: a negative consequence for the behavior. (Ms. Graves 
said that “no scrutiny or outside influence impacts the rating of any 
film — period.”)

The board, according to these people, thought the scene was uproariously 
funny and could leave children with a strong message that smoking 
marijuana is fun. The opposite, of course, could be argued: One way to 
make young people think that marijuana is uncool is to show the 
white-haired Mr. Martin, 64, smoking it.

This emphasis on consequences has long been part of how Hollywood has 
navigated taboo subjects, dating back to the Hays Code era, said Robert 
Sklar, an emeritus professor of cinema studies at New York University 
and the author of “Movie-Made America.” “If somebody transgressed — 
infidelity, alcoholism — they had to pay for it,” he said.

The M.P.A.A. is often accused by conservative groups of “ratings creep,” 
a loosening of standards as the years go on, and of pandering to the 
studios, which resist R ratings because it could limit the audience. But 
“It’s Complicated” may be an example of the reverse.

Ms. Graves said the board has grown more strict about drug use over the 
last two decades. “In the ’60s and ’70s, drugs were considered fun and 
recreational, but then parents started to wise up and standards shifted 
the other way,” she said.

In other words, “9 to 5” was born of a different cultural time.

It is hard to argue, however, that cannabis has become anything but more 
routine over the years. There are now about 1,000 medical marijuana 
dispensaries in the Los Angeles area alone, according to city estimates; 
as a point of reference, there are fewer than 300 Starbucks outposts.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to