[Gee, what could be wrong with giving away taxpayer funds to subsidize 
private companies operating within monopoly cartels (professional sports 
teams)?]

December 25, 2009

As Revenue Plunges, Stadium Boom Adds to Municipal Woes
By KEN BELSON
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/25/sports/25stadium.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


CINCINNATI — Years after a wave of construction brought publicly 
financed stadiums costing billions of dollars to cities across the 
country, taxpayers are once again being asked to reach into their pockets.

 From New Jersey to Ohio to Arizona, the stadiums were sold as a key to 
redevelopment and as the only way to retain sports franchises. But the 
deals that were used to persuade taxpayers to finance their construction 
have in many cases backfired, the result of overly optimistic revenue 
assumptions and the recession.

Nowhere is the problem more acute than in Cincinnati. In 1996, voters in 
Hamilton County approved an increase of half of one percent in the sales 
tax that promised to build and maintain stadiums for the Bengals and the 
Reds, pay Cincinnati’s public schools and give homeowners an annual 
property tax rebate. The stadiums were supposed to spur development of 
the city’s dilapidated riverfront.

But sales tax receipts have fallen so fast in the last year that the 
county is now scrambling to bridge a $14 million deficit in its sales 
tax fund. The public schools, which deferred taking their share for 
years, want their money.

The teams have not volunteered to rewrite their leases. So in the coming 
weeks, the county plans to cut basic services, lower its legal bills and 
drain a bond reserve fund with no plan for paying it back.

“Anyone looking at this objectively knows it’s a train wreck,” said 
Dusty Rhodes, the county auditor. “I told them they were making a big 
mistake, but they didn’t want to hear me.”

Cincinnati is hardly alone. In Indianapolis, the Capital Improvement 
Board spent 2009 trying to find $32 million to run the Lucas Oil Stadium 
and convention center. In Milwaukee, a drop in sales tax receipts may 
delay by several years the date for paying off the bonds issued to build 
Miller Park, the home of the Brewers.

Columbus, Ohio, is considering using public money to keep the Blue 
Jackets in town. Glendale, Ariz., has fought to hold the Phoenix Coyotes 
to their long-term lease. In New Jersey, a ticket surcharge may be added 
to help resolve a tenant-landlord dispute between the Devils and Newark.

Mark Rosentraub, the author of the book “Major League Losers,” said that 
many of the stadium deals included “revenue bombs,” with financial traps 
like balloon payments on debt in later years and sweeteners like the 
Hamilton County property tax rebate to win public support.

In many cases, the architects of the deals are long gone by the time the 
bill comes due.

“This is one of the effects of the economic tsunami sweeping through,” 
Rosentraub said of the deficits.

The 1996 proposal to build stadiums for the Bengals and the Reds had 
plenty of proponents. The economy was growing, Riverfront Stadium was 
outdated and the Bengals were hinting that they would move, as the 
Browns had done.

The plan went awry almost from the start. The football stadium exceeded 
its budget by $50 million, forcing the county to issue more bonds. 
Forecasts for growth in the sales tax turned out to be too rosy. The 
teams received sweetheart leases. In 2000, voters threw out the county 
commissioners who cut the deal.

That year the sales tax grew 1.8 percent, the first of many years below 
the 3 percent forecast. Both stadiums were originally expected to cost 
$500 million combined. Yet Paul Brown Stadium alone cost $455 million 
and the Great American Ballpark, the Reds’ home a few hundred yards down 
the Ohio River, cost $337 million by the time it opened in 2003.

The generous deal for the Bengals has been a sore spot. The team had to 
pay rent only through 2009 on its 26-year lease, and has to cover the 
cost of running the stadium only for game days. Starting in 2017, the 
county will reimburse the team for these costs, too. The county will pay 
$8.5 million this year to keep the stadium going.

The Bengals keep revenue from naming rights, advertising, tickets, 
suites and most parking. If the county wants to recoup money by taxing 
tickets, concessions or parking, it needs the team’s approval.

Compared with the lucrative deals for teams in Baltimore, St. Louis and 
elsewhere, the Bengals won a particularly lopsided lease.

Bob Bedinghaus, the commissioner who spearheaded the stadium project, 
said as much in 2000.

“They’re an organization that’s run by lawyers, and they look for every 
penny around every corner,” he told The Cincinnati Enquirer. “It’s going 
to be a difficult relationship going forward for the next 30 years.”

Bedinghaus lost his re-election bid soon after. He now works as the 
Bengals’ director of stadium development. Through a team spokesman, 
Bedinghaus declined to be interviewed. The Bengals also declined to 
comment. Several telephone and e-mail attempts to reach the Reds’ 
management were unsuccessful.

Hamilton County started using some of the proceeds from the sales tax 
fund to jump-start construction of a redevelopment district with the 
stadiums as bookends. After years of delays, cranes dot the riverfront 
that will eventually include a hotel, shops and hundreds of homes.

Critics like Rhodes contend that the tax was never meant to pay for the 
real estate project. But Cincinnati business leaders, eager to reverse 
the flow of money to the suburbs, say the stadiums were just the 
beginning of a transformation of the riverfront.

“We need to build this neighborhood so that it becomes the center of 
someplace you want to go,” said Thomas L. Gabelman, the outside counsel 
for the county on the riverfront development.

Gabelman said that most of the money for the $1.2 billion project comes 
from federal and state grants and private financing. No more than $3 
million annually comes from the sales tax fund, which brings in about 
$60 million a year.

Problems persist. In 2004, Todd Portune, the commissioner who unseated 
Bedinghaus, sued unsuccessfully to change the Bengals’ lease. In 2006, 
the Cincinnati public schools agreed to defer their payments from the 
sales tax fund for three years to help cover shortfalls.

Still, the gap between expected and actual sales taxes continues to 
grow, something the county administration had been warning for years. In 
August, the administrator predicted not only a $14 million shortfall 
next year, but also a $94 million gap in 2014, a year after interest 
payments on the stadium bonds rise 44 percent. By then, the Reds will no 
longer be paying rent.

Last month, two of the three commissioners voted against cutting the 
property tax rebate, fearing a voter backlash. Raising the sales tax 
again was not proposed for the same reason.

“It can’t be 100 percent on the backs of taxpayers,” said Greg Hartmann, 
the lone Republican commissioner. “We gave away too much to keep the 
Bengals in Cincinnati. There has to be some middle ground.”

Hartmann and Portune want to introduce a tobacco tax, but lawmakers in 
Columbus, the state capital, may be unwilling to approve it.

So they have ordered more cuts in basic county administrative services, 
something that creates a slippery slope, said David Pepper, the 
commissioner who voted against the proposal.

“It’s like the movie where the blob keeps growing and eating away at 
other elements of county government,” Pepper said. “We’re beginning to 
cross a line in the sand by taking money from the general fund to pay 
for the stadiums. Once you put that money in jeopardy, you put the whole 
county at risk.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to