December 25, 2009

Where There’s Smoke ... There’s a Trade-In
By ABBY GOODNOUGH
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/25/business/energy-environment/25stove.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


KEENE, N.H. — The wood stove was blazing in Rosemary Urato’s living room 
on Christmas Eve, giving off a hypnotic glow and only a hint of smoky 
smell. It is brand new and cleaner than its predecessor, which was 
dispatched to a scrapyard last month.

There it joined dozens of others — sooty Tempwoods and All Nighters, 
squat Vermont Castings and Fishers etched with pines — recently 
discarded by Keene residents. In return, the state gave the residents 
$1,000 toward the cost of a new stove that meets current emissions 
requirements.

“The old one was a little scary,” said Steve Perkins, Ms. Urato’s landlord.

A spin on the federal Cash for Clunkers program, which helped people 
trade gas guzzlers for more efficient vehicles, the program is a small 
step toward clearing the air in rural New England, a tradition-bound 
region that has clung to its wood stoves for sentimental reasons even as 
much of the country has declared them passé. It aims to replace 100 old 
stoves in Keene, population 23,000, by February.

Because the town sits in a valley, fine-particle pollution — the kind 
that wood smoke creates — gets trapped near the ground on cold, calm 
days. An air monitor regularly detects worrisome levels that could 
ultimately violate federal standards, triggering tough restrictions on 
wood burning.

Such restrictions could extend to periodic bans on burning wood or 
manufactured logs in fireplaces, too, as the San Francisco Bay Area has 
done. The agency that monitors air quality there said it would ban wood 
fires on Christmas because of predictions for cold, still weather. 
Residents who want to watch a burning Yule log will have to resort to 
television.

Keene is among some 35 communities nationwide that have offered exchange 
programs in recent years, according to the Environmental Protection 
Agency, which estimates that more than 7,500 wood stoves and fireplaces 
have been replaced as a result.

In Keene, the cash-for-wood-clunkers program has drawn about 70 takers, 
and, among some residents, a flinty response — and a sense that they 
know better than bureaucrats, whom some suspect of exaggerating the risk 
posed by old stoves.

Deb Ferguson, a real estate agent who said she burned four cords of wood 
each winter in her old Tempwood stove, went to a meeting about the 
program but it left her wary.

“Don’t get me wrong — I love a good coupon,” Ms. Ferguson said, sitting 
at her kitchen table in a toasty home across from a horse farm. “But 
there’s too much government bureaucracy around it.”

In particular, she said she doubted one thing officials at the meeting 
said: that an old stove can emit as much pollution as seven diesel buses.

“I was like, ‘How the heck do you know that?’ ” Ms. Ferguson said. 
“There are days when I’ll go outside and say, ‘That smells horrible,’ 
but honestly I think there are a lot of bigger trees they should be 
barking up.”

In Northern California, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District has 
relied on neighbors to report violators, as well as the so-called 
fireplace police — teams of inspectors who fan across the region on ban 
days looking for chimney smoke. People caught burning wood get a warning 
for the first violation and a $400 fine for the second. Last winter, the 
district got more than 1,400 complaints from the nine counties it monitors.

There are some 10 million wood stoves in use in the United States, 
according to the E.P.A., and while the agency has set new emissions 
limits for those made after 1990, most are older.

Those stoves use more wood and emit up to 10 times more particle 
pollution than newer ones, according to the E.P.A.

In California, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District has imposed 
wood-burning bans on 14 days so far since November 2008. People who rely 
exclusively on wood heat are exempt, but one of them, Sandy Clark of 
Woodacre, Calif., said she felt singled out nonetheless.

“I get nasty notes from someone here in town on my woodpile,” Mrs. 
Clark, 65, said. “There is one woman who walks up and down the street 
looking for smoke in people’s chimneys. She has her own spies — kids and 
other women who walk around with notebooks, looking for smoke.”

In Vermont, more than 200 wood stoves were turned in this year under a 
program that provided vouchers worth $450, said Heidi Hales, the state 
official who oversaw it.

A program, in Libby, Mont., helped replace more than 1,000 old stoves 
from 2005 to 2007. Afterward, a study by the University of Montana found 
that outdoor particulate pollution decreased by 30 percent and indoor 
pollution by 70 percent.

A climate-change bill before Congress would authorize $20 million over 
five years for a national wood stove exchange program, but the bill’s 
fate is uncertain.

In the meantime, said Alison Simcox, who studies air quality for the New 
England region of the E.P.A., the economic downturn has kept such 
programs from spreading at the state and county level. “Everybody likes 
the idea,” Ms. Simcox said. “But we’re not going to see a lot of it with 
the recession.”

Gary Goodemote, one of four stove dealers participating in the Keene 
exchange program, said substitutes cost from $1,500 for the most basic 
new stove to $4,000 for top-of-the-line pellet stoves, which burn 
compressed wood pellets and are cleaner.

Mr. Goodemote said that although oil prices had dropped this year, many 
homeowners were still buying stoves out of fear that prices would spike 
again.

New Englanders, he said, treat their old stoves like cherished friends.

And, he added, “they can’t imagine their old friend going onto the scrap 
heap.”

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to