February 11, 2013
Waste Is Seen in Program to Give Internet Access to Rural U.S.
By EDWARD WYATT
NY Times
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/12/technology/waste-is-seen-in-program-to-give-internet-access-to-rural-us.html
AGATE, Colo. — The bank is gone from this once-thriving ranching and
farming community on Colorado’s windblown eastern plain, as are the
dairies, the hotel and the Union Pacific depot. The post office remains,
at the corner of Main Street and First Avenue, the intersection of the
town’s two paved streets.
There is not much that is modern in Agate, except at the 11-student
elementary school, which has three high-speed fiber optic Internet
connections — more than nearly every school in Denver, 70 miles to the
west, and, for that matter, just about any school in the country. And it
is something, the school says, that it doesn’t need.
The latest chapter in Agate’s recent broadband boom came thanks to the
$4 billion Broadband Technology Opportunities Program, part of the Obama
administration’s 2009 economic stimulus effort. The aim of the grant
program is to extend high-speed Internet access to parts of the country
that had little or none of it because private companies said it was too
expensive to build.
“These investments have the potential to reshape our nation,” said
Lawrence E. Strickling, an assistant commerce secretary and the
administrator of the National Telecommunications and Information
Administration, which runs the federal grant program. “We know that
Americans who don’t have access to the Internet are increasingly cut off
from job opportunities, education resources, health care information and
even government services.”
But local phone companies have complained about waste or unfair
competition, like using some of the grants to build fiber networks where
they already exist — including, in Colorado, in the easily accessible
eastern plains that include Agate — rather than where they are most
needed, in rural mountain towns.
Nationally, $594 million in spending has been temporarily or permanently
halted, 14 percent of the overall program, and the Commerce Department’s
inspector general has raised questions about the program’s ability to
adequately monitor spending of the more than 230 grants.
In Illinois, for example, a $12 million broadband grant was sanctioned
when a subcontractor was caught routing fiber optic cable through
neighborhoods where its project engineers lived. A $39 million grant in
Arizona was suspended over questionable expenditures on travel,
transactions that appeared to involve conflicts of interest and other
unbudgeted activities.
Broadband grants in Alabama and Louisiana, totaling $140 million, were
terminated over undocumented expenditures and failure to adhere to
construction plans and schedules. Four other grants, worth $42 million,
returned the money before even getting off the ground.
Here in Agate, two high-speed connections already existed in the school,
which had been teaching students from kindergarten through 12th grade.
Now the oldest students are fifth graders, and the school says the
high-speed fiber optic service is of little use and beyond its means.
(It has requested bids for a slower-speed connection to replace it.)
Agate’s third fiber optic connection was among the projects built with
funds from a $100 million grant to an education consortium called called
Eagle-Net. The grant has been suspended since December, when officials
discovered that Eagle-Net had changed nearly all of its plans for wiring
the state. Four months earlier, Eagle-Net was warned about questionable
spending and lack of budgetary controls, according to Commerce
Department documents.
Congress is preparing to take a closer look at the overall program.
Representative Cory Gardner, a Colorado Republican whose district
includes Agate, said in an interview Monday that the House subcommittee
overseeing the grant program was preparing for a hearing into possible
program waste.
Eagle-Net says it has tried to work with the rural telecom companies.
Gretchen Dirks, a spokeswoman, said several of the rural telephone
companies now raising objections supported Eagle-Net’s plans in the
beginning.
Ms. Dirks also said Eagle-Net had not been avoiding mountain areas. “The
more difficult-to-reach areas of Colorado, due to diverse geographic and
weather conditions, have been slated for completion in 2013 since the
very beginning of the funding process,” she said.
Obama administration officials say that the problem with certain grants,
including Eagle-Net’s, are being addressed. But it is misleading, they
say, to focus on the 14 grants that have been suspended or terminated
when most have been successful. (Five of the programs whose grants were
suspended are back up and running.)
Among the more promising, Mr. Strickling said, were a $102 million
program in Arkansas that has paid for high-speed video and data links
between rural doctors’ offices and the state university’s medical center
in Little Rock, and a $33 million grant to build a 1,000-mile fiber loop
linking communities in rural northern Georgia to Atlanta.
Rural areas certainly suffer a lack of high-speed Internet access. While
about 88 percent of urban households in the United States have access to
high-speed cable Internet service, only 40 percent of rural households
do, according to the Federal Communications Commission and the Commerce
Department.
About 20 percent of United States households have access to fiber optic
Internet service, the fastest connection, compared with 86 percent in
Japan and two-thirds in South Korea. But the Eagle-Net experience in
Colorado demonstrates that in the haste to get broadband everywhere,
some grant planners appeared not to have taken into account the current
condition of infrastructure.
Among the earliest fiber optic connections that Eagle-Net turned on, for
example, was not in a remote, unserved area but in the Cherry Creek
School District, located in a wealthy Denver suburb.
Ben Startzer, chief information officer for Cherry Creek schools, said
in an interview that before Eagle-Net came to visit, the district
already had a fiber optic connection that operated at 300 megabits per
second — 100 times faster than the average residential broadband speed.
The schools didn’t need the new network, Mr. Startzer said, but it
allowed the district to nearly double its speed while increasing the
network’s backup redundancy.
A two-hour drive to the east, in Flagler, Colo., the 180-student public
school, which serves prekindergarten through 12th grade, also recently
got a third fiber optic connection, thanks to Eagle-Net, whose cable was
installed underground within a few feet of fiber optic cables already
laid by Eastern Slope Rural Telephone.
Eastern Slope’s network was financed in part by an $18 million loan from
the Department of Agriculture’s Rural Utilities Service — which, unlike
Eagle-Net’s grant, has to be repaid.
“Here you have a quasi-governmental agency that has free federal money
and is spending it to provide the exact same service that is already
there, competing against companies that are borrowing federally backed
money,” said Senator Greg Brophy, a Colorado state legislator whose
district covers a large swath of rural northeastern Colorado.
The types of local government institutions that Eagle-Net is focusing on
are often the largest customers of the rural telecommunications
companies, said Kevin Felty, president of the Colorado
Telecommunications Association and president of Plains Cooperative
Telephone.
Revenue from those larger entities supports affordable residential
service in the area, he said.
Ms. Dirks of Eagle-Net said that if local institutions were happy with
the service they already had, they would not have welcomed a new provider.
One of those enthusiastic about Eagle-Net is Brainstorm Internet, of
Durango, Colo. Russ Elliott, president of Brainstorm, said connecting to
Eagle-Net had allowed his company to offer substantially faster service
that costs less to provide than before. “They came in and said ‘What can
we do to help you get to these rural communities?’ ” he said.
In Agate, however, Daniel Hollembeak, general manager of the Agate
Mutual Telephone, whose headquarters are in a mobile home across a dirt
lot from the school, said Eagle-Net’s wiring of schools and other
government institutions would drive companies like his further toward
the brink.
“We employ local people,” he said. “If Eagle-Net takes away these
institutions, it will have a big negative effect on the company.”
--
=================================================
George Antunes Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor Fax (713) 743-3927
Political Science Mail: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net