Obama administration defends $222,000 file-sharing verdict
Government urges Supreme Court not to review Minnesota woman's huge penalty.
by Timothy B. Lee
Ars Technica
Feb 12 2013, 2:50pm CST
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/02/obama-administration-defends-222000-file-sharing-verdict/
The Obama Administration has stepped into a long-running file-sharing
lawsuit in Minnesota, urging the United States Supreme Court not to get
involved in a six-figure verdict against a young mother from Northern
Minnesota. The feds don't buy the woman's argument that the massive size
of the award makes it unconstitutional.
Jammie Thomas-Rasset has been fighting a recording industry lawsuit
accusing her of sharing music using the now-defunct peer-to-peer network
Kazaa for the better part of a decade. In 2007, a jury found
Thomas-Rasset liable to the tune of $222,000 for sharing 24 songs. She
appealed the verdict, resulting in two more trials that each produced
even larger jury awards. These higher figures were thrown out by the
courts, but last year, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the
$222,000 award.
Thomas-Rasset is now seeking review by the Supreme Court. In a December
brief, her lawyer drew an analogy to a line of Supreme Court decisions
regarding excessive punitive damages. In those cases, juries had awarded
punitive damages that were more than 100 times larger than the actual
damages suffered by the plaintiffs. The Supreme Court held that such
disproportionate punitive damages violate the due process clause of the
Constitution.
Technically, the "statutory damages" Thomas-Rasset is facing are not
classified as punitive damages. But her lawyer argues that the same
logic ought to apply. The 24 songs at issue in the case can be
downloaded from iTunes for $24, yet she is being ordered to pay almost
10,000 times as much for sharing them with others.
Thomas-Rasset's lawyer notes that Thomas-Rasset's trial judge "called
for relief from Congress, and throughout his opinions called the
statutory damages sought by the recording industry harsh and oppressive."
But in a brief filed Monday, the Obama administration rejected
Thomas-Rasset's argument and urged the Supreme Court not to consider her
appeal. It noted that lower courts agreed with the defense in principle
that an award could be "so severe and oppressive as to be wholly
disproportioned to the offense and obviously unreasonable." Indeed, the
trial judge had rejected a $1.5 million jury award on just those
grounds. But the lower courts had concluded that a $222,000 award for
sharing 24 songs was not so disproportionate and unreasonable as to
violate the Constitution. And in the government's view, the Supreme
Court should let that judgement stand.
"The public interest cannot be realized if the inherent difficulty of
proving actual damages leaves the copyright holder without an effective
remedy for infringement," the government's brief argues. Large penalties
may be needed to adequately deter infringement. And while the range of
possible damages established by Congress—between $750 and $150,000 per
infringed work—may seem excessive to some, "Congress’s judgment as to
the appropriate amounts is entitled to deference."
Unsurprisingly, the recording industry also opposed Thomas-Rasset's
petition for a Supreme Court review of her case. "Jammie Thomas-Rasset’s
copyright infringement was willful in the extreme," says a Monday brief
from several major labels. "Three separate juries have concluded that
her blatant and unapologetic violation of Respondents’ rights warranted
a substantial award under the Copyright Act’s statutory damages
provision." The recording industry insists that the six-figure penalty
is justified in light of Thomas-Rasset's "particularly blameworthy conduct."
Thomas-Rasset faces long odds. Before she can make her case on the
merits, the court must agree to hear her appeal. The Supreme Court
accepts only a fraction of the appeals submitted to it, and in May it
declined to review the case of Joel Tenenbaum, who like Thomas-Rasset is
still fighting the recording industry in court.
--
=================================================
George Antunes Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor Fax (713) 743-3927
Political Science Mail: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net