Online legal publishers squabble over the right to copyright the law Do
private online publishers own the law, or does it belong to the people?

*Feb 11, 2016 1:05pm CST*


*by David KravetsMultichannel News*
http://www.multichannel.com/news/content/cbs-all-access-considering-ad-free-service/402539

Well, it's OK to copy the actual law. But if you copy the state-ordered
summaries...

Two big-name legal research companies are battling in federal court over
the right to exclusively publish the law—in this case, the Georgia
Administrative Rules and Regulations.

The lawsuit
<http://ia801500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.0.pdf>
(PDF)
comes as states across the nation partner with legal research companies to
offer exclusive publishing and licensing deals for digitizing and making
available online the states' reams of laws and regulations. The only
problem is that the law is not copyrightable—or so says one of the
publishers involved in the Georgia litigation. In this instance, District
of Columbia-based legal publisher Fastcase wants a judge to fend off a
cease-and-desist demand from rival Virginia-based Lawriter, which has been
designated as the exclusive publisher
<http://ia601500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.1.pdf>
(PDF)
of Georgia's compilation
<http://ia601500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.2.pdf>
(PDF)
of the rules and regulations of its state agencies. The lawsuit says:

The Georgia Regulations are binding law—a broad-ranging collection of rules
and regulations governing areas from consumer protection to banking to
elections. The Georgia Regulations are promulgated by public agencies of
the State of Georgia, and published for the benefit of the public by the
Georgia Secretary of State, as required by O.C.G.A. § 50-13-7. Defendant
Lawriter purports to have exclusive rights to publish the Georgia
Regulations. Consistent with this claim of exclusive rights, Lawriter has
sent Plaintiff Fastcase a demand that Fastcase remove the Georgia
Regulations from its legal research service, which is provided as a free
member benefit to members of the State Bar of Georgia. The Georgia
Regulations are public law published under statutory mandate and are in the
public domain. Defendant cannot claim any exclusive right in, to, or in
connection with, the Georgia Regulations. Thus, Fastcase seeks declaratory
judgment that Lawriter has no basis from which to prohibit Fastcase from
publishing the Georgia Regulations in its subscription legal research
service.

Fastcase also says Lawriter "cannot claim a valid copyright or an exclusive
license to a valid copyright. It is well established in American law that
state laws, including administrative rules and regulations, are not
copyrightable, and must remain public as a matter of due process."

In Lawriter's demand letter, Lawriter says Fastcase has been illegally
offering its customers access to the "Georgia Administrative rules and
Regulation Electronic Files."

"According to Lawriter's records, however, Fastcase has not entered into a
subscription with Lawriter for the Electronic Files and therefore appears
to be offering the Electronic Files without Lawriter's consent or
authorization, and in violation of Lawriter's legal rights." The demand
letter
<http://ia801500.us.archive.org/3/items/gov.uscourts.gand.224009/gov.uscourts.gand.224009.1.3.pdf>
(PDF)
requests that Fastcase cease the online publishing of Georgia's law or
"purchase a subscription." The letter also demands "Fastcase immediately
provide a written response substantiating its rights to its use of the
Electronic Files." Instead, Fastcase sued.

Fastcase CEO Ed Walters told Ars by e-mail: "This case deals with a small
library, but the issues are larger and very important. The law is the last,
great walled garden on the Internet, at a time when access to justice is a
greater problem than ever. From here, things could go either way. This
could be the beginning of an age of open government—or states could partner
with private publishers who copyright or paywall the law. We're not going
to sit back and watch this happen. When Lawriter threatened to sue us for
using public law, it was time to stand up."

Georgia has already defended its right to license the law and is suing
<http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/georgia-sues-legal-rebel-for-posting-states-copyrighted-law-online/>
legal rebel Public.Resource.org <https://public.resource.org/>, based in
California, for publishing the Peach State's laws. That case is pending.

"It's a big deal," Carl Malamud, who runs Public.Resource.org, said in an
e-mail to Ars. He said the Fastcase-Lawriter litigation "presents the same
issues as our case: Can you speak the law without a license from the state?
We say anybody can read and speak the law in America because the people own
the law."
_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews_etskywarn.net

Reply via email to